Abstract:The spatial resolution of EEG/MEG source estimates, often described in terms of source leakage in the context of the inverse problem, poses constraints on the inferences that can be drawn from EEG/MEG source estimation results. Software packages for EEG/MEG data analysis offer a large choice of source estimation methods but few tools to experimental researchers for methods evaluation and comparison. Here, we describe a framework and tools for objective and intuitive resolution analysis of EEG/MEG source estimation based on linear systems analysis, and apply those to the most widely used distributed source estimation methods such as L2-minimum-norm estimation (L2-MNE) and linearly constrained minimum variance (LCMV) beamformers. Within this framework it is possible to define resolution metrics that define meaningful aspects of source estimation results (such as localization accuracy in terms of peak localization error, PLE, and spatial extent in terms of spatial deviation, SD) that are relevant to the task at hand and can easily be visualized. At the core of this framework is the resolution matrix, which describes the potential leakage from and into point sources (point-spread and cross-talk functions, or PSFs and CTFs, respectively). Importantly, for linear methods these functions allow generalizations to multiple sources or complex source distributions. This paper provides a tutorial-style introduction into linear EEG/MEG source estimation and resolution analysis aimed at experimental (rather than methods-oriented) researchers. We used this framework to demonstrate how L2-MNE-type as well as LCMV beamforming methods can be evaluated in practice using software tools that have only recently become available for routine use. Our novel methods comparison includes PLE and SD for a larger number of methods than in similar previous studies, such as unweighted, depth-weighted and normalized L2-MNE methods (including dSPM, sLORETA, eLORETA) and two LCMV beamformers. The results demonstrate that some methods can achieve low and even zero PLE for PSFs. However, their SD as well as both PLE and SD for CTFs are far less optimal for all methods, in particular for deep cortical areas. We hope that our paper will encourage EEG/MEG researchers to apply this approach to their own tasks at hand.

Règles de sélection de variables pour accélerer la localisation de sources en MEG et EEG sous contrainte de parcimonie

Multi-subject MEG/EEG source imaging with sparse multi-task regression

Solving large-scale MEG/EEG source localization and functional connectivity problems simultaneously using state-space models

Debiased Estimation and Inference for Spatial-Temporal EEG/MEG Source Imaging

Mixed-norm estimates for the M/EEG inverse problem using accelerated gradient methods

The iterative reweighted Mixed-Norm Estimate for spatio-temporal MEG/EEG source reconstruction

Mind the duality gap: safer rules for the Lasso

Sparse wavelet-based solutions for the M/EEG inverse problem

A Novel EEG Source Localization Method Based on FOCUSS Iteration Procedure Combined with Lp Norm Sparse Constraints

Sparse EEG Source Localization Using LAPPS: Least Absolute L-P (0<p<1) Penalized Solution.

EEG source localization using a sparsity prior based on Brodmann areas

Towards an objective evaluation of EEG/MEG source estimation methods - The linear approach

Comparison of inverse problem linear and non-linear methods for localization source: a combined TMS-EEG study

Sparse Bayesian Learning for EEG Source Localization

Multiple Signal Classification Based on Genetic Algorithm for MEG Sources Localization

PDE-constrained optimization for electroencephalographic source reconstruction

Requirements for Coregistration Accuracy in On-Scalp MEG

Effcient magnetometer sensor array selection for signal reconstruction and brain source localization

A Sparse EEG-Informed fMRI Model for Hybrid EEG-fMRI Neurofeedback Prediction

A Novel Bayesian Approach for EEG Source Localization

Algorithmes De Type Homotopiques Pour La Minimisation Des Moindres Carrés Régularisés Par La "norme" $\Ell_0$