Abstract:Purpose The field of international business (IB) formally welcomes and frequently calls for case study research, but the proportion of case study papers appearing in IB journals remains very small. This paper aims to support efforts to redress this imbalance by addressing an overlooked yet critical issue: the (mis)use of tenses when theorizing from case study findings. The authors reveal a pervasive use of the present tense and argue that this leads to decontextualization and, in turn, over-generalization. The paper also suggests ways in which this problem may be avoided in the future, thereby improving the credibility and status of case-based research and helping to de-marginalise it within IB. Design/methodology/approach A qualitative content analysis was applied to all (2,627) papers published between 2011 and 2021 in four leading IB journals. In total, 171 case study papers were identified over these 11 years, and a deeper content analysis was then performed to measure the extent of decontextualization/over-generalization implied by the inappropriate use of the present tense in the discussion and theorisation of research findings. Findings This study found that, out of 171 case study papers identified, 141 (82.5%) provided at least two instances of over-generalization as implied by the misuse of the present tense. However, some of these papers were found to feature statements that could be claimed to mitigate such inappropriate generalization. These mitigating factors included the repeated use of adverbial phrases denoting context and the use of a "propositional style" that clearly distinguished contextual findings from speculative, decontextualized generalizations. Nevertheless, 71 of the 171 (41.5%) papers still demonstrated inappropriate generalization, even after allowing for mitigating factors. Originality/value This study reveals a problematic writing practice and one which has arguably significantly contributed to the "decontextualization" problem critiqued in IB and management studies more broadly. The study also offers further insights into how decontextualization might be avoided, arguing that this problem would be significantly reduced if tenses were used appropriately in discussing and theorizing case study findings. Additionally, the study highlights the continued marginalization of qualitative research methods in IB and reinforces calls to address it.

evidence of case study research in Business Management:

Case study research: opening up research opportunities

The Concept of Evidence: Its History of Evolution and Its Epistemological Reconstruction

The Definition and Measurement of "Evidence" in Evidence-Based Management

Case Selection Biases in Management Research: the Implications for International Business Studies

Case research in operations management

The case study method in family business research: Guidelines for qualitative scholarship

Improving the credibility of case study research in international business studies and beyond: a simple fix for a serious problem

Case report papers guidelines: Recommendations for the reporting of case studies or action research in Business Management

Identifying Research Fields within Business and Management: A Journal Cross-Citation Analysis

The Case Study Method in Philosophy of Science: An Empirical Study

Are rigor and transparency enough? Review and future directions for case studies in technology and innovation Management

Case Study Method: A Step-by-Step Guide for Business Researchers

Towards a Methodology for Developing Evidence-Informed Management Knowledge by Means of Systematic Review

Discussion on the Methodology of Case Study in Management Research

Designing for impact: the effect of rigor and case study design on citations of qualitative case studies in management

Systematic case study research: A practice-oriented introduction to building an evidence base for counselling and psychotherapy

The Study of Evidence-based Health Management

The curious case of case study research

Achieving Better Educational Practices Through Research Evidence: A Critical Analysis and Case Illustration of Benefits and Challenges