Abstract:Abstract The pervasiveness of Computer Science (CS) in today’s digital society and the extensive use of computational methods in other sciences call for its introduction in the school curriculum. Hence, Computer Science Education is becoming more and more relevant. In CS K-12 education, computational thinking (CT) is one of the abused buzzwords: different stakeholders (media, educators, politicians) give it different meanings, some more oriented to CS, others more linked to its interdisciplinary value. The expression was introduced by two leading researchers, Jeannette Wing (in 2006) and Seymour Papert (much early, in 1980), each of them stressing different aspects of a common theme. This paper will use a historical approach to review, discuss, and put in context these first two educational and epistemological approaches to CT. We will relate them to today’s context and evaluate what aspects are still relevant for CS K-12 education. Of the two, particular interest is devoted to “Papert’s CT,” which is the lesser-known and the lesser-studied. We will conclude that “Wing’s CT” and “Papert’s CT,” when correctly understood, are both relevant to today’s computer science education. From Wing, we should retain computer science’s centrality, CT being the (scientific and cultural) substratum of the technical competencies. Under this interpretation, CT is a lens and a set of categories for understanding the algorithmic fabric of today’s world. From Papert, we should retain the constructionist idea that only a social and affective involvement of students into the technical content will make programming an interdisciplinary tool for learning (also) other disciplines. We will also discuss the often quoted (and often unverified) claim that CT automatically “transfers” to other broad 21st century skills. Our analysis will be relevant for educators and scholars to recognize and avoid misconceptions and build on the two core roots of CT.

Integrating computational thinking into K-12 education: Bridging the gap between theories and practices

Assessing Students' Computational Thinking In A Learning By Modeling Environment

Computational Thinking from a Disciplinary Perspective: Integrating Computational Thinking in K-12 Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics Education

Integration of computational thinking in K-12 mathematics education: a systematic review on CT-based mathematics instruction and student learning

Integrating computational thinking with K-12 science education using agent-based computation: A theoretical framework

Computational thinking in primary education: a systematic literature review

Computational Thinking in Education: Where does it Fit? A systematic literary review

The computational thinking for science (CT-S) framework: operationalizing CT-S for K–12 science education researchers and educators

Interdisciplinary Integration of Computational Thinking in K-12 Education: A Systematic Review

Put two and two together: A systematic review of combining computational thinking and project-based learning in STEM classrooms

Computational Thinking in Introductory Physics

Computational thinking in early childhood education: Reviewing the literature and redeveloping the three-dimensional framework

How do Teachers Apply Computational Thinking Activities in Elementary School? From Continuing Education to the classroom

Instructional practices promoting computational thinking in STEAM elementary classrooms

Learning Culture and Computational Thinking in a Spanish Course: A Development Model

Computational Thinking, Between Papert and Wing

A review of Project-Based Learning (PBL) and Computational Thinking (CT) in teaching and learning

Computational Thinking for Science: Positioning coding as a tool for doing science

Computational Thinking and Metacognition

A literature review on the empirical studies of the integration of mathematics and computational thinking

Algorithmic Explanations: an Unplugged Instructional Approach to Integrate Science and Computational Thinking