A cross-sectional analysis of negation used in thesis writing by L1 and L2 PhD students
Xuelan Li,Feng Jiang,Jing Ma,Feng (Kevin) Jiang
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jeap.2023.101264
IF: 2.811
2023-07-01
Journal of English for Academic Purposes
Abstract:PhD theses have received considerable attention over years, playing a crucial role for PhD students to represent external realities and create writer-reader relations. To engage with alternative voices in textual interaction, PhD students produce their texts through the use of negation along with other interpersonal devices. Additionally, negation as an important rhetorical device performs both interactive and interactional functions. Nevertheless, little research has systematically investigated the use of negation in PhD theses across sections. Drawing on two corpora of students’ theses, we therefore analyse the differences in the frequency, distribution, and function of negation between L1 and L2 PhD students. Results showed that both L1 and L2 PhD students tended to employ various negative markers across sections, especially in the results and discussion, literature review, methodology, and conclusion sections. However, L2 PhD students employed fewer negative markers than L1 PhD students. Additionally, in terms of functional uses, L2 PhD students employed fewer negative markers in both interactive and interactional dimensions across sections. The findings of this study enable a better understanding of the rhetorical functions of negation and provide some pedagogical implications for the instruction of PhD thesis writing.
education & educational research,linguistics