A Corpus-Based Study on the Diachronic Relationship Between the Contemporary American English Present Perfect and Simple Past Across Registers.
Xiaowen Zhang,Yunhua Qu,Zhiwei Feng
2019-01-01
Glottometrics
Abstract:The relationship between the diachronic change of the present perfect (PP) and the past simple tense (SP) in English has always been an important, but still puzzling subject of studies on the English aspect-tense system, because the two constructions are both related to past-time reference, and the distinction between the two is not clear-cut in many English varieties. Even contexts labeled by temporal adverbials - like yesterday, which tends to be used with the SP, or since, which is usually combined with the PP - have become increasingly compatible with the other construction. Therefore, it is assumed that the diachronic change of the PP or the SP should not be studied individually, as is done in many previous studies, but observed from a broader perspective - the competition between the two. This study, using the largest and most balanced American English corpus, COCA (The Corpus of Contemporary American English), aims to investigate the diachronic change patterns of the PP and the SP, as well as to detect their relationship, in five different registers (Spoken, Fiction, Magazines, Newspapers, and the Academic one). Findings show that the diachronic change of the PP or the SP is closely related, either negatively (i.e. competitively) or positively in the entire corpus, except for the Academic register. To be more specific, the development of the PP and the SP are in competition in COCA and the Spoken register, while positively related in Fiction, Magazine, and Newspaper. No statistically significant correlation is found in the Academic one. This research adds the dimension of register into the study of the diachronic change of the English tense-aspect system, adopting relatively convincing statistical methods to reveal a panorama about the relationship between the development of the PP and the SP in contemporary American English.