Impact of the first wave of COVID-19 epidemy on the surgical management of sigmoid diverticular disease in France: National French retrospective study

Camille Gil,Laura Beyer-Bergeot,Charles Sabbagh,Philippe Zerbib,Valérie Bridoux,Gilles Manceau,Yves Panis,Etienne Buscail,Aurélien Venara,Iman Khaoudy,Martin Gaillard,Manon Viennet,Alexandre Thobie,Benjamin Menahem,Clarisse Eveno,Catherine Bonnel,Jean-Yves Mabrut,Bodgan Badic,Camille Godet,Yassine Eid,Emilie Duchalais,Zaher Lakkis,Eddy Cotte,Anais Laforest,Véronique Defourneaux,Léon Maggiori,Lionel Rebibo,Niki Christou,Ali Talal,Diane Mege,Cécile Bonnamy,Adeline Germain,François Mauvais,Christophe Tresallet,Jean Roudie,Alexis Laurent,Bertrand Trilling,Martin Bertrand,Damien Massalou,Benoit Romain,Hadrien Tranchart,Urs Giger,Arnaud Alves,Mehdi Ouaissi,Alexandra Pellegrin,Jean Marc Regimbeau,Julien Gillet,Antoine Hamy,Amine Lahmidi,Mohamed Sebbagh,Antoine Bres,Nicolas Girard,Aurélie Desjouis,Nadjib Ainseba,Julien Epailly,Fabienne Huysman,Maud Dezeustre,Alexandre Doussot,Célia Turco,Diane Bourrhis,Morgane Finocchi,Yoan Marion,Gil Lebreton,Flavie Benard,Elodie Pineau,Véronique Bouvier,Olivier Dejardin,Pablo Ortega Deballon,Nathan Moreno-Lopez,Patrick Rat,Bassem Makar,Paola Fara,Marc Pompilio,Hugo Hertault,Corentin Guezennec,Habchi Saida,Alexandre Brinza,Laurent Plard,Antoine Ailhaud,Léa Gutierrez,Vincent Venchiarutti,Jean-Luc Faucheron,Bertrand Morin,Bertrand Pech de la clause,Eglantine Voitellier,Guillaume Gagnat,Barbara Noiret,Constance Laroye,Guillaume Piessen,Katia Lécolle,Jean Robert,Nzamushelepanmabla,Perrine Engel,Muriel Mathonnet,Cyprien Rodriguez,Ammar Makki,Anne-Cécile Couchard,François Duramé,Cécile Marceau,Jean-Christophe Paquet,Vahan Kepenekian,Guillaume Passot,Olivier Glehen,Ninon Wallach,Kayvan Mohkam,Marie-Caroline Blanc,Stéphane Berdah,Mathilde Aubert,Ahmet Ayav,Hervé Chanty,Alexandre Didier,Estelle Vigneron,Noémie Périard,Marie Thaumoux,Océane Grenouilloux,Seila Fall,Sophoclis Thomareis,Chloé Marsollier,Michel Prud’homme,Christos Antonopulos,Simon Msika,Marie Monsinjon,Massimo Giacca,Antoine Cazelles,Mehdi Karoui,Valentina Malerba,Ibrahim Dagher,Nicola de Angelis,Francesco Brunetti,Omar Ahmed,Jean-Marc Ferraz,Yassir Ramjaun,Christine Denet,Basile Fuchs,Daniel Pietrasz,Pénélope Raimbert,Juliette Benedetti,Chloé Coton,Hélène Corte,Aude Medrignac,Daphné Chavrier,Robin Girard,Julia Berthelot,Matthieu Monge,Eloïse Papet,Jean Pinson,Elise Dolbeau,Jean-Jacques Tuech,Julien Chautard,Mathilde Boullier,François Goujard,Laurent Perrot,Ludovic Loge,Jean-Michel Petiot,Simone Mandefredelli,Diane Charleux-Muller,Guillaume Sauvinet,Jean-Baptiste Bertin,Louis Vincent,Blandine Simeu,Jean-Baptiste Delhorme,Cécile Brigand,Serge Rohr,Manon Bouchet,Jean-Pierre Duffas,Laurent Ghouti,Antoine Philis,Guillaume Portier,Elias Karam,Nicolas Michot,Alice Artus,Emilien Mauny,Pierre-olivier Jouppe,Céline Bourbao-Tournois,Hugo Barbin,Julien Thiery,
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00384-023-04564-w
IF: 2.8
2023-12-02
International Journal of Colorectal Disease
Abstract:ObjectiveTo analyze the surgical management of sigmoid diverticular disease (SDD) before, during, and after the first containment rules (CR) for the first wave of COVID-19.MethodsFrom the French Surgical Association multicenter series, this study included all patients operated on between January 2018 and September 2021. Three groups were compared: A (before CR period: 01/01/18–03/16/20), B (CR period: 03/17/20–05/03/20), and C (post CR period: 05/04/20–09/30/21).ResultsA total of 1965 patients (A n = 1517, B n = 52, C n = 396) were included. The A group had significantly more previous SDD compared to the two other groups (p = 0.007), especially complicated (p = 0.0004). The rate of peritonitis was significantly higher in the B (46.1%) and C (38.4%) groups compared to the A group (31.7%) (p = 0.034 and p = 0.014). As regards surgical treatment, Hartmann’s procedure was more often performed in the B group (44.2%, vs A 25.5% and C 26.8%, p = 0.01). Mortality at 90 days was significantly higher in the B group (9.6%, vs A 4% and C 6.3%, p = 0.034). This difference was also significant between the A and B groups (p = 0.048), as well as between the A and C groups (p = 0.05). There was no significant difference between the three groups in terms of postoperative morbidity.ConclusionThis study shows that the management of SDD was impacted by COVID-19 at CR, but also after and until September 2021, both on the initial clinical presentation and on postoperative mortality.
gastroenterology & hepatology,surgery
What problem does this paper attempt to address?