Predicting wait time for pediatric kidney transplant: a novel index

Alexandra Alvarez,Ashley Montgomery,Nhu Thao Nguyen Galván,Eileen D. Brewer,Abbas Rana

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00467-023-06232-1

2024-01-12

Pediatric Nephrology

Abstract:Abstract Background Over one thousand pediatric kidney transplant candidates are added to the waitlist annually, yet the prospective time spent waiting is unknown for many. Our study fills this gap by identifying variables that impact waitlist time and by creating an index to predict the likelihood of a pediatric candidate receiving a transplant within 1 year of listing. This index could be used to guide patient management by giving clinicians a potential timeline for each candidate’s listing based on a unique combination of risk factors. Methods A retrospective analysis of 3757 pediatric kidney transplant candidates from the 2014 to 2020 OPTN/UNOS database was performed. The data was randomly divided into a training set, comprising two-thirds of the data, and a testing set, comprising one-third of the data. From the training set, univariable and multivariable logistic regressions were used to identify significant predictive factors affecting wait times. A predictive index was created using variables significant in the multivariable analysis. The index’s ability to predict likelihood of transplantation within 1 year of listing was validated using ROC analysis on the training set. Validation of the index using ROC analysis was repeated on the testing set. Results A total of 10 variables were found to be significant. The five most significant variables include the following: blood group, B (OR 0.65); dialysis status (OR 3.67); kidney disease etiology, SLE (OR 0.38); and OPTN region, 5 (OR 0.54) and 6 (OR 0.46). ROC analysis of the index on the training set yielded a c-statistic of 0.71. ROC analysis of the index on the testing set yielded a c-statistic of 0.68. Conclusions This index is a modest prognostic model to assess time to pediatric kidney transplantation. It is intended as a supplementary tool to guide patient management by providing clinicians with an individualized prospective timeline for each candidate. Early identification of candidates with potential for prolonged waiting times may help encourage more living donation including paired donation chains. Graphical Abstract

pediatrics,urology & nephrology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### Problems the paper attempts to solve

The paper aims to solve the problem of predicting the waiting time for pediatric kidney transplantation. Specifically, the research identifies the key variables that affect the waiting time and creates an index to predict the probability of pediatric kidney transplant candidates receiving a transplant within one year after being placed on the waiting list. This index can serve as a supplementary tool for clinicians in managing patients, helping doctors better understand the patients' waiting time by providing a personalized estimated timeline for each candidate.

### Research background

Each year, more than 1,000 pediatric kidney transplant candidates are added to the waiting list, but many candidates are not clear about the expected waiting time. This paper fills this gap by identifying the variables that affect the waiting time and creating a predictive index to help clinicians provide personalized waiting - time estimates for each candidate.

### Main findings

1. **Significant variables**:
- Blood type B (OR 0.65)
- Hemodialysis status (OR 3.67)
- Etiology of kidney disease, systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) (OR 0.38)
- OPTN regions 5 (OR 0.54) and 6 (OR 0.46)

2. **Predictive index**:
- This index is constructed using the significant variables in the multivariate analysis, and its predictive ability is verified by ROC analysis. The c - statistic value of the training set is 0.71, and the c - statistic value of the test set is 0.68, indicating that this index is a moderate prognostic model.

### Conclusion

This index is a moderate prognostic model for evaluating the time of pediatric kidney transplantation. It is intended to be a supplementary tool for clinicians in managing patients, helping doctors better understand the patients' waiting time by providing a personalized estimated timeline for each candidate. Early identification of candidates who may need to wait for a long time is helpful in encouraging more living donations, including paired - donation chains.

### Formula

The calculation formula of the predictive index is as follows:

\[
\text{index} = \exp\left( (- 0.19 \text{ if Blood Group B})+(0.31 \text{ if Blood Group AB})+(0.57 \text{ if on Dialysis})+(- 0.36 \text{ if Weight }0 - 10\text{kg})+(- 0.23 \text{ if Weight }10 - 20\text{kg})+(- 0.42 \text{ if dx of SLE})+(- 0.27 \text{ if in Region 5})+(- 0.33 \text{ if in Region 6})+(- 0.24 \text{ if in Region 9})+(0.22 \text{ if in Region 10}) \right)
\]

### Discussion

This is the first study specifically on the factors affecting the waiting time for pediatric kidney transplantation. Although some factors in adult studies (such as PRA status, blood type, and age) also have a significant impact on children, ethnic differences did not show significance in this study. This may be because minority patients become transplant candidates only in the late stage of the disease, or the 2014 KAS update has successfully reduced ethnic differences. In addition, the impact of geographical regions on the waiting time has also been confirmed, especially that patients in OPTN regions 5, 6, and 9 have a longer waiting time.