Correlation effects in ionic crystals: I. The cohesive energy of MgO

Klaus Doll,Michael Dolg,Peter Fulde,Hermann Stoll

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevB.52.4842

1995-06-02

Abstract:High-level quantum-chemical calculations, using the coupled-cluster approach and extended one-particle basis sets, have been performed for (Mg2+)n (O2-)m clusters embedded in a Madelung potential. The results of these calculations are used for setting up an incremental expansion for the correlation energy of bulk MgO. This way, 96% of the experimental cohesive energy of the MgO crystal is recovered. It is shown that only 60% of the correlation contribution to the cohesive energy is of intra-ionic origin, the remaining part being caused by van der Waals-like inter-ionic excitations.

Condensed Matter

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is to evaluate whether the hadron spectrum under the "quenched approximation" is consistent with the experimental results. Specifically, the author studied the light - quark meson spectrum through lattice gauge theory and paid special attention to the mass ratio of vector mesons and pseudoscalar mesons.

### Summary of main problems:
1. **Evaluating the meson spectrum under the quenched approximation**: The paper aims to verify through lattice QCD calculations whether the meson spectrum under the quenched approximation can accurately reflect the experimental results.
2. **Comparing theoretical and experimental results**: The author compared the meson spectrum obtained from quenched QCD with experimental data, especially the mass differences between pseudoscalar and vector mesons.
3. **Introducing a new dimensionless combination \(J\)**: In order to better compare theoretical and experimental results, the author introduced a dimensionless combination \(J = m_V\frac{dm_V}{dm_P^2}\), which is invariant under different lattice spacings and hopping parameters, thus avoiding extrapolation to the singularity limit.

### Specific problem description:
- **Mass relationship between vector mesons and pseudoscalar mesons**: The author used multiple operators (including smooth and local operators) to extract the masses of the ground state and the first excited state to ensure the reliability of the results.
- **Verification of mass formulas**: By adjusting the quark mass and studying the meson behavior at different masses, the mass formulas of vector mesons and pseudoscalar mesons were verified.
- **Analysis of systematic errors**: Systematic errors caused by different fitting ranges, relevant fitting methods, etc. were considered to ensure the accuracy of the results.

### Conclusion:
The paper found that there are significant differences between the meson spectrum under quenched QCD and the experimental results, especially in the masses of pseudoscalar and vector mesons. This indicates that the quenched approximation may not be able to fully capture certain physical effects in real QCD, emphasizing the importance of further studying the effects of dynamic quarks.

### Key formulas:
- Pseudoscalar meson mass formula: \[m_P^2(q_1, q_2)=b(q_1 + q_2)\]
- Vector meson mass formula: \[m_V(q_1, q_2)=d + c(q_1 + q_2)\]
- Dimensionless combination \(J\): \[J = m_V\frac{dm_V}{dm_P^2}\]

These formulas are used to describe the change of meson mass with quark mass and are verified by lattice calculations.