Abstract:Companies are increasingly using artificial intelligence (AI) to provide performance feedback to employees, by tracking employee behavior at work, automating performance evaluations, and recommending job improvements. However, this application of AI has provoked much debate. On the one hand, powerful AI data analytics increase the quality of feedback, which may enhance employee productivity ("deployment effect"). On the other hand, employees may develop a negative perception of AI feedback once it is disclosed to them, thus harming their productivity ("disclosure effect"). We examine these two effects theoretically and test them empirically using data from a field experiment. We find strong evidence that both effects coexist, and that the adverse disclosure effect is mitigated by employees' tenure in the firm. These findings offer pivotal implications for management theory, practice, and public policies. Managerial abstract Artificial intelligence (AI) technologies are bound to transform how companies manage employees. We examine the use of AI to generate performance feedback for employees. We demonstrate that AI significantly increases the accuracy and consistency of the analyses of information collected, and the relevance of feedback to each employee. These advantages of AI help employees achieve greater job performance at scale, and thus create value for companies. However, our study also alerts companies to the negative effect of disclosing using AI to employee that results from employees' negative perceptions about the deployment of AI, which offsets the business value created by AI. To alleviate value-destroying disclosure effect, we suggest that companies be more proactive in communicating with their employees about the objectives, benefits, and scope of AI applications in order to assuage their concerns. Moreover, the result of the allayed negative AI disclosure effect among employees with a longer tenure in the company suggests that companies may consider deploying AI in a tiered instead of a uniform fashion, that is, using AI to provide performance feedback to veteran employees but using human managers to provide performance feedback to novices.

Perceived Fairness of Human Managers Compared with Artificial Intelligence in Employee Performance Evaluation

How is the AI Perceived when It Behaves (Un)fairly?

Navigating the Manager-AI Divide

Can AI Algorithmic Decision-making Improve Employees’ Perception of Procedural Fairness?

Who do you choose? Employees' perceptions of artificial intelligence versus humans in performance feedback

When the Automated Fire Backfires: the Adoption of Algorithm-based HR Decision-making Could Induce Consumer's Unfavorable Ethicality Inferences of the Company

The Impact of Artificial Intelligence Replacing Humans in Making Human Resource Management Decisions on Fairness: A Case of Resume Screening

Applicants' Fairness Perception of Human and AI Collaboration in Resume Screening

The Janus Face of Artificial Intelligence Feedback: Deployment Versus Disclosure Effects on Employee Performance

Understanding Relations Between Perception of Fairness and Trust in Algorithmic Decision Making

Is AI Better Than Human in Identifying High-Potential Talents: A Quasi-Field Experiment.

Relationship between Perceived Fairness of Performance Appraisal and Employees′ Performance under Difference Matrices

AI Decision Making with Dignity? Contrasting Workers’ Justice Perceptions of Human and AI Decision Making in a Human Resource Management Context

Employees Adhere More to Unethical Instructions from Human Than AI Supervisors: Complementing Experimental Evidence with Machine Learning

Designing Fair AI in Human Resource Management: Understanding Tensions Surrounding Algorithmic Evaluation and Envisioning Stakeholder-Centered Solutions

AI-Powered Employee Performance Evaluation Systems in HR Management

The Mixed Blessing of Leaders’ Artificial Intelligence (AI)-oriented Change Behavior: Implications for Employee Job Performance and Unethical Behavior

Artificial intelligence as a boundary-crossing object for employee engagement and performance

Saving face: Leveraging artificial intelligence‐based negative feedback to enhance employee job performance

Who should be first? How and when AI-human order influences procedural justice in a multistage decision-making process

The Use of the Analytic Hierarchy Process in Improving Psychological Empowerment and Employee Performance