Abstract:In a series of seminal papers, Laddha and Varadarajan have developed in depth the quantisation of Parametrised Field Theory (PFT) in the kind of discontinuous representations that are employed in Loop Quantum Gravity (LQG). In one spatial dimension (circle) PFT is very similar to the closed bosonic string and the constraint algebra is isomorphic to two mutually commuting Witt algebras. Its quantisation is therefore straightforward in LQG like representations which by design lead to non anomalous, unitary, albeit discontinuous representations of the spatial diffeomorphism group. In particular, the complete set of (distributional) solutions to the quantum constraints, a preferred and complete algebra of Dirac observables and the associated physical inner product has been constructed. On the other hand, the two copies of Witt algebras are classically isomorphic to the Dirac or hypersurface deformation algebra of General Relativity (although without structure functions). The question we address in this paper, also raised by Laddha and Varadarajan in their paper, is whether we can quantise the Dirac algebra in such a way that its space of distributional solutions coincides with the one just described. This potentially teaches us something about LQG where a classically equivalent formulation of the Dirac algebra in terms of spatial diffeomorphism Lie algebras is not at our disposal. We find that, in order to achieve this, the Hamiltonian constraint has to be quantised by methods that extend those previously considered. The amount of quantisation ambiguities is somewhat reduced but not eliminated. We also show that the algebra of Hamiltonian constraints closes in a precise sense, with soft anomalies, that is, anomalies that do not cause inconsistencies. We elaborate on the relevance of these findings for full LQG.

Regularization of the Hamiltonian constraint and the closure of the constraint algebra

Quantum Geometrodynamics Revived I. Classical Constraint Algebra

Anomaly freedom in effective Loop Quantum Cosmology: pedagogical summary and generalized holonomy corrections

Regularisation by Hamiltonian extension

Symplectic Quantization and General Constraint Structure of a Prototypical Second-Class System

Gauge Symmetry Breaking Lattice Regularizations and their Continuum Limit

Spherically Symmetric Sector of Self Dual Ashtekar Gravity Coupled to Matter: Anomaly-free Algebra of Constraints with Holonomy Corrections

A qubit regularization of asymptotic freedom without fine-tuning

Quantum Reduced Loop Gravity: Extension to Gauge Vector Field

On the dynamics of single-vertex states in quantum-reduced loop gravity

Consistency of the Regularization of Gauge Theories by High Covariant Derivatives

Manifestly covariant canonical quantization of gravity and diffeomorphism anomalies in four dimensions

Regularization of matrices in the covariant derivative interpretation of matrix models

Anomalies and Wess-Zumino Terms in an Extended, Regularized Field-Antifield Formalism

Effective actions, cutoff regularization, quasi-locality, and gluing of partition functions

A Note On The Canonical Formalism for Gravity

Lessons for Loop Quantum Gravity from Parametrised Field Theory

On the Regularity of Hamiltonian Stationary Lagrangian manifolds

Hamilton-Jacobi framework for Regge-Teitelboim gravity

Dependence of the Gauss-law Constraints on the Regularization Scheme in Non-Abelian Chiral Gauge Theory