Abstract:Biological systems with many components often exhibit seemingly critical behaviors, characterized by atypically large correlated fluctuations. Yet the underlying causes remain unclear. Here we define and examine two types of criticality. Intrinsic criticality arises from interactions within the system which are fine-tuned to a critical point. Extrinsic criticality, in contrast, emerges without fine tuning when observable degrees of freedom are coupled to unobserved fluctuating variables. We unify both types of criticality using the language of learning and information theory. We show that critical correlations, intrinsic or extrinsic, lead to diverging mutual information between two halves of the system, and are a feature of learning problems, in which the unobserved fluctuations are inferred from the observable degrees of freedom. We argue that extrinsic criticality is equivalent to standard inference, whereas intrinsic criticality describes fractional learning, in which the amount to be learned depends on the system size. We show further that both types of criticality are on the same continuum, connected by a smooth crossover. In addition, we investigate the observability of Zipf's law, a power-law rank-frequency distribution often used as an empirical signature of criticality. We find that Zipf's law is a robust feature of extrinsic criticality but can be nontrivial to observe for some intrinsically critical systems, including critical mean-field models. We further demonstrate that models with global dynamics, such as oscillatory models, can produce observable Zipf's law without relying on either external fluctuations or fine tuning. Our findings suggest that while possible in theory, fine tuning is not the only, nor the most likely, explanation for the apparent ubiquity of criticality in biological systems with many components.

Criticality in Simple Models of Evolution

Self-organized criticality in evolutionary systems with local interaction

Extrinsic vs Intrinsic Criticality in Systems with Many Components

Are biological systems poised at criticality?

Colloquium: Criticality and dynamical scaling in living systems

Self-organized criticality via stochastic partial differential equations

Algorithmic Mapping Criticality into Self Organized Criticality

Self-organization without conservation: true or just apparent scale-invariance?

Phase Transitions and Criticality in the Collective Behavior of Animals -- Self-organization and biological function

Criticality and the Onset of Ordering in the Standard Vicsek Model

Dynamical Criticality: Overview and Open Questions

Critical Transitions In a Model of a Genetic Regulatory System

Self-Organized Criticality in Nonconserved Systems.

Self-Organized Criticality in a Transient System

Large-Scale Mass Distribution Behind the Galactic Plane

Self-organized criticality in a network of economic agents with finite consumption

Microdynamics and Criticality of Adaptive Regulatory Networks

Criticality as It Could Be: organizational invariance as self-organized criticality in embodied agents

Self-Organized Cooperative Criticality in Coupled Complex Systems

Extinction events and species lifetimes in a simple ecological model

Geometric models of (d+1)-dimensional relativistic rotating oscillators