Abstract:1. Detecting and dealing with spatial autocorrelation (SA) are indispensable steps in analyses of geospatial data. Despite consensus that SA originates from both extrinsic factors and intrinsic interactions, previous studies on regression analysis of spatially autocorrelated data have rarely controlled for intrinsic sources in addition to extrinsic ones to assess ceteris paribus (i.e. causal) effects of interest, with the strict exogeneity assumption that errors containing unexplained variance are uncorrelated with explanatory variables for all observations. This assumption becomes invalid when intrinsic SA is not an external process modelled as errors and needs to be controlled for. 2. Here, we aimed to assess the extent to which not controlling for intrinsic SA negatively affects model performance, specifically in terms of type I error rate and unbiasedness of coefficient estimates, and to identify models that are able to handle these problems. To this end, we applied two categories of regression models that do (intrinsic category) or do not (extrinsic category) explicitly control for intrinsic SA to artificial data generated with both SA sources. These models included the extended spatial Durbin model (ESDM) and its nested models. Four analytic scenarios simulated modelling conditions with increasing complexity of variables omitted during modelling. The two more complex scenarios involved additional violations of strict exogeneity. 3. We found that intrinsic-just as extrinsic-SA can produce incorrect type I error rates, if not explicitly controlled for. Failing to control for intrinsic SA also generated bias in estimates of ceteris paribus effects. However, ESDM from the intrinsic category exhibited consistently good performance in dealing with intrinsic SA across all the scenarios, but suffered other violations of strict exogeneity. 4. Overall, model specification should control for both extrinsic and intrinsic processes generating SA in spatial data to provide reliable type I error rates and unbiased estimates of ceteris paribus effects. Given the likely widespread occurrence in observational spatial data of unknown or unmeasurable processes, ESDM should be a generally preferred starting point to explore the optimal model specification for estimating ceteris paribus effects, with due caution to other violations of strict exogeneity.

To use, or not to use the spatial Durbin model? – that is the question

Spatial Regression Models: A Systematic Comparison of Different Model Specifications Using Monte Carlo Experiments

Spatial Autocorrelation Approaches to Testing Residuals from Least Squares Regression.

Identification of Spatial Durbin Panel Models

Robust Variable Selection with Exponential Squared Loss for the Spatial Durbin Model

Heteroskedasticity Robust Specification Testing In Spatial Autoregression

Effects of Intrinsic Sources of Spatial Autocorrelation on Spatial Regression Modelling

DOUBLE LENGTH ARTIFICIAL REGRESSIONS FOR TESTING SPATIAL DEPENDENCE

Estimating a Spatial Autoregressive Model with an Endogenous Spatial Weight Matrix

Understanding and extending the geographical detector model under a linear regression framework

Spatial Unit Roots and Spurious Regression

Spatial autoregressive model with measurement error in covariates

Semiparametric estimation of a spatial autoregressive nonparametric stochastic frontier model

When Space Matters: Spatial Dependence, Diagnostics, and Regression Models

A Monte Carlo comparison of GMM and QMLE estimators for short dynamic panel data models with spatial errors

Evaluating the performance of AIC and BIC for selecting spatial econometric models

Semiparametric spatial autoregressive models with nonlinear endogeneity

Birnbaum–Saunders spatial modelling and diagnostics applied to agricultural engineering data

A semiparametric dynamic higher-order spatial autoregressive model

A Problem with Distance Variables and Alternatives for Their Use

A backward elimination discrete optimization algorithm for model selection in spatio-temporal regression models