Abstract:Alternatives to fossil fuels as energy carriers are required to reach global climate targets. Hydrogen and ammonia are promising candidates that are carbon emission-free at point of combustion. Ammonia is critically important for fertiliser production and thus global food production. Additionally, low-carbon ammonia is a potentially valuable fuel for shipping, power generation, and industry. However, ammonia production today accounts for about 2% of total global carbon dioxide emissions. Conventional ammonia production based on methane reforming can be decarbonised by using carbon capture and storage, creating so-called blue ammonia. Alternatively, low-carbon electricity from additional clean energy sources can be used for electrolytic (green) hydrogen and ammonia production. Production tax credits (PTC) for clean hydrogen production via the 45V and carbon sequestration via the 45Q under the Inflation Reduction Act (IRA) in the United States have sparked interest in large-scale commercial low-carbon ammonia projects. In this work, we analyse different blue and green low-carbon ammonia production processes under economic and practical considerations. We propose and evaluate two novel designs: Integrating a biomethane supply into the reformer; and combining blue and green ammonia production processes. Results show that all low-carbon ammonia plants can significantly reduce emissions compared to the conventional process. With the production tax credits, blue ammonia is likely to be the most economical production route in the near-term, being cheaper than conventional ammonia which is not eligible for any credits. The economics of green ammonia depend heavily on the price of reliable low-carbon electricity. A levelised cost of electricity of about 35 $/MWh and lower is required for green ammonia to be competitive with blue ammonia at average gas prices and upstream emissions. Of the two novel process designs, blending in biomethane shows promise as it can lead to carbon-neutral or even carbon-negative ammonia with a near-zero cost of production when supported by 45V. Blue-green ammonia on the other hand can improve economics if upstream emissions are small and low-carbon electricity is cheap. Overall, the IRA tax credits improve the economics of low-carbon ammonia production significantly and result in it being competitive with conventional ammonia production, enabling significant carbon emission reduction.

LCA comparison analysis for two types of H 2 carriers: Methanol and ammonia

Hydrogen Production Via Ammonia from Methane Integrated with Enhanced Oil Recovery: A Techno-Economic Analysis

A near-zero carbon emission methanol production through CO2 hydrogenation integrated with renewable hydrogen: Process analysis, modification and evaluation

A Comparative Environmental Life Cycle Assessment of the Combustion of Ammonia/Methane Fuels in a Tangential Swirl Burner

Life cycle analysis of ammonia and methane production using green hydrogen and carbon dioxide

Life-cycle Analysis of Methanol Production from Coke Oven Gas in China

Life cycle assessment of selected ammonia production technologies from the perspective of ammonia as a fuel for heavy-duty vehicle

Comparative life cycle assessment and economic analysis of methanol/hydrogen production processes for fuel cell vehicles

Comprehensive life cycle cost analysis of ammonia-based hydrogen transportation scenarios for offshore wind energy utilization

Comparative environmental assessment of methanol production technologies: A cradle-to-gate life cycle analysis

Decarbonizing the energy supply chain: Ammonia as an energy carrier for renewable power systems

Low carbon pathway and life cycle assessment of ammonia co-firing in coal power plants under the context of carbon neutrality

Techno-economic analysis of hydrogen transportation infrastructure using ammonia and methanol

Large-scale production and transport of hydrogen from Norway to Europe and Japan: Value chain analysis and comparison of liquid hydrogen and ammonia as energy carriers

Life cycle Assessment of Hydrogen Production via Natural Gas Steam Reforming vs. Biomass Gasification

A prospective life cycle assessment of global ammonia decarbonisation scenarios

Critical Review of Life Cycle Assessment of Hydrogen Production Pathways

Techno-environmental assessment of small-scale Haber-Bosch and plasma-assisted ammonia supply chains

A comparative techno-economic assessment of blue, green, and hybrid ammonia production in the United States

It is not the same green: A comparative LCA study of green hydrogen supply network pathways

Sustainable Ammonia Production Processes