Review of Productivity Machines: German Appropriations of American Technology From Mass Production to Computer Automation by Corinna Schlombs
Devin Kennedy
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1109/mahc.2022.3215212
2022-12-10
IEEE Annals of the History of Computing
Abstract:The book provides a methodologically innovative and archivally rich story about the idea of productivity and the machines that promise to deliver it. Speaking to audiences across the histories of technology, diplomacy, economic ideas, labor, and political economy, the author offers a novel transatlantic framing of capitalism in the middle of the 20th century and its relation to technology, including computers. At the heart of the book are a series of interactions between workers, managers, and political figures from the United States and Germany, from the Weimar era to the 1950s about the notion of productivity and how it should be pursued. The author's story of automation offers an innovative model for work at the intersection of the history of capitalism and computing. In drawing on a comparative analysis of the German and United States experience of productivity in the middle decades of the 20th century, Productivity Machines casts new light on the relationship between technology and political economy. Automation and other managerial efforts to enhance productivity were controversial in both countries, the author shows, not only because they augured job losses, but because they revealed the contours of each nation's "variety of capitalism" and laid bare the power relations within it. Discussions of productivity made clear the limits of, or need for, labor power in corporate decision-making, revealed the vulnerability of a welfare system based on employer benefits, and drew attention to the limited benefits of mass production when untethered from wage gains that could sustain mass consumption.
history & philosophy of science,computer science, theory & methods