Abstract:As the online channel is crucially important, traditional offline retail stores seek to induce their existing consumers to buy online with incentives (i.e., offline-to-online targeting). However, it is debatable whether such targeting is truly effective. While advocates argue that online shopping should complement a firm's store channel, critics counter that doing so may result in cannibalization. Drawing on the channel interplay literature and considering customers' travel costs, we examine whether and how inducing online shopping complements or cannibalizes a firm's offline sales. Using a randomized field experiment on over 11,200 customers of a large department store, we provide causal evidence for both the complementarity and cannibalization effects of online and offline channels. Offline-to-online targeting engenders higher online purchases (as intended) than no targeting. The local average treatment effects models suggest that once induced to buy online, consumers who live near the retailer's physical store tend to increase their offline spending and total sales by 47% (i.e., complementarity effects for nearby consumers). However, for consumers who live far away from the brick-and-mortar store, inducing them to buy online can backfire by reducing offline and total sales by approximately 5.7% for each additional kilometer of distance (i.e., cannibalization effects for distant consumers). Explorations of these mechanisms suggest that distant consumers who are induced to buy online may fail to return to shop in the offline store and purchase less experiential category products with a smaller basket size than other customers, thus leading to a negative net impact on the total sales. These findings alert managers to the dangers of improper targeting and investment in information technology and the importance of consumer heterogeneity for omnichannel commerce across online and offline channels.

Spillover effects between competitive brands——based on the comparison of cross-border e-commerce and offline store scenarios

Effects of online-to-offline spillovers on pricing and quality strategies of competing firms

Spillover Effect of Content Marketing in E-commerce Platform under the Fan Economy Era.

Online or offline? Spillover effect of customer-to-customer interaction in a multichannel background

Manufacturer’s online selling strategies under spillovers from online to offline sales

The effects of external cues on cross-border e-commerce product sales: An application of the elaboration likelihood model

The Death of Language Barriers? an Empirical Study Based on China’s Cross-Border E-Commerce

The effect of shopping channel (online vs offline) on consumer decision process and firm's marketing strategy

Targeted Promotions and Cross-Category Spillover Effects

When and how should a retailer use third-party platform channels? The Impact of spillover effects

Study of the horizontal competition of dual-channel retailer and traditional retailer with congestion negative effect of physical channel

Study on the Impact of Online and Offline Cross Experience on Consumers' Shopping Channel Choice

Consumer Preferences, Cannibalization and Competition: Evidence from the Personal Computer Industry

Research on the Influence of Time-honored Cross-border Product Market Matching Degree on Purchase Intention

Relationship between Online Shopping and Store Shopping in the Shopping Process: Empirical Study for Search Goods and Experience Goods in Nanjing, China

Research on the Impact of Cross-border E-commerce Platform Quality on Customer Cross-buying Intention

Understanding the Substitution Effect Between Online and Traditional Channels: Evidence from Product Attributes Perspective.

Which Receives More Attention, Online Review Sentiment or Online Review Rating? Spillover Effect Analysis from JD.com

Complementarity and Cannibalization of Offline-to-Online Targeting: A Field Experiment on Omnichannel Commerce

Does the Effect of Customer Experience on Customer Satisfaction Create a Sustainable Competitive Advantage? A Comparative Study of Different Shopping Situations

Research on the Influence of Spillover Effect on dual-channel supply chain under the Background of Live-Streaming Marketing