Does the Effect of Customer Experience on Customer Satisfaction Create a Sustainable Competitive Advantage? A Comparative Study of Different Shopping Situations

Xue-Liang Pei,Jia-Ning Guo,Tung-Ju Wu,Wen-Xin Zhou,Shang-Pao Yeh
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/su12187436
IF: 3.9
2020-09-10
Sustainability
Abstract:With the rapid development of online shopping and traditional physical store shopping interweaving to form different shopping situations, customer experience has gradually become the main source of retailers’ sustainable competitive advantage through differentiation. Retailers need to continuously improve customer experience in different shopping situations to maintain long-term sustainable customer satisfaction and achieve sustainability. The study aims to examine what kind of shopping situations will influence customer experience and customer satisfaction. A total of 288 questionnaires were collected from two different shopping situations (146 questionnaires from physical stores were collected in five cities in China and 142 online questionnaires were collected from 21 provinces in China), and multiple regression analysis was adopted to test the hypotheses. As a result, we found that customer experience with staff service, shopping environment, and shopping procedure has a positive influence on customer satisfaction. Different shopping situations significantly moderate the relationships among customer experience with the shopping environment, product experience, and customer satisfaction but rarely influence customer experience with staff service and service procedures. Finally, gender significantly moderates the relationship between customer experience and customer satisfaction in different shopping situations. This study theoretically reveals the relationship between customer experience and satisfaction in different shopping situations and provides practical suggestions for retailers to form differentiated sustainable competitive advantage through customer experience management.
environmental sciences,environmental studies,green & sustainable science & technology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper primarily explores the relationship between customer experience and customer satisfaction, and analyzes how different shopping contexts (online shopping and physical store shopping) and gender factors moderate this relationship, aiming to provide theoretical basis and practical suggestions for retailers to create sustainable competitive advantages. ### Research Questions 1. **The relationship between customer experience and customer satisfaction**: The study aims to examine the impact of product experience, service process experience, shopping environment experience, and employee service experience on customer satisfaction in different shopping contexts. 2. **The role of different shopping contexts**: Investigate how different shopping contexts (online and offline) influence the relationship between various customer experiences and customer satisfaction. 3. **The impact of gender factors**: Analyze how gender moderates the relationship between customer experience and customer satisfaction, with a particular focus on the differences between male and female customers in different shopping contexts. ### Main Contributions - Provides a comprehensive framework to understand the complex relationship between customer experience and customer satisfaction. - Empirically validates the moderating effects of different shopping contexts and gender on the relationship between customer experience and satisfaction. - Offers theoretical support and practical guidance for retailers to develop differentiated strategies, helping them gain sustainable competitive advantages in an increasingly competitive market. In summary, the core issue this paper attempts to address is understanding how customer experience affects customer satisfaction and exploring how different shopping contexts and gender moderate this process, with the ultimate goal of helping retailers form differentiated sustainable competitive advantages.