The horizon of cross-cultural understanding: a case study of Jock Tuzo Wilson's One Chinese Moon

Leilei Chen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/13645140903465050

2010-02-01

Studies in Travel Writing

Abstract:This article explores the question of cross-cultural understanding by reading One Chinese Moon (1960), a book that records Canadian geophysicist Jock Tuzo Wilson's travel to Great Leap Forward China in 1958. As a transcultural traveller, Wilson is able to see the distance between common assumptions about the visited country and the reality he witnesses during his travel. His awareness of such distance does not overcome his limitations as an observer, but nonetheless results in his providing the reader with nuanced, comparative observations of the travelled culture and his home culture. With privileged hindsight, we see that on most occasions the traveller cannot transcend the limit of history and his realm of knowledge when representing the visited place, which always puts his cultural translation in question. Nevertheless, his travel showcases a conscious effort to reach an understanding of China based upon his recognition of the common ground underneath striking national, cultural, and political disparities. His is an understanding that comprehends cultural difference not as an obstacle to knowing a foreign culture, but as a puzzle that elicits interest in that culture and causes an urge to learn the culture better. The process of cultural translation not only brings about an insightful vision of the traveller's original culture but also results in a global consciousness or a cosmopolitan conviction that casts into doubt the constructed boundaries between nations and cultures. Rather than pursuing an authentic version of a real China at the time of Wilson's travel – if such a version exists at all – this article questions the binarism represented in the existing discourse of and about travel writing by reading a neglected travel account.