Abstract:Causal inference has become an important research direction in the field of computing. Traditional methods have mainly used Bayesian networks to discover the causal effects between variables. These methods have limitations, namely, on the one hand, the computing cost is expensive if one wants to achieve accurate results, i.e., exponential growth along with the number of variables. On the other hand, the accuracy is not good enough if one tries to reduce the computing cost. In this study, we use prior knowledge iteration or time series trend fitting between causal variables to resolve the limitations and discover bidirectional causal edges between the variables. Subsequently, we obtain real causal graphs, thus establishing a more accurate causal model for the evaluation and calculation of causal effects. We present two new algorithms, namely, the PC+ algorithm and the DCM algorithm. The PC+ algorithm is used to address the problem of the traditional PC algorithm, which needs to enumerate all Markov equivalence classes at a high computational cost or with immediate output of non-directional causal edges. In the PC+ algorithm, the causal tendency among some variables was analyzed via partial exhaustive analysis. By fixing the relatively certain causality as prior knowledge, a causal graph of higher accuracy is the final output at a low running cost. The DCM algorithm uses the d-separation strategy to improve the traditional CCM algorithm, which can only handle the pairwise fitting of variables, and thus identify the indirect causality as the direct one. By using the d-separation strategy, our DCM algorithm achieves higher accuracy while following the basic criteria of Bayesian networks. In this study, we evaluate the proposed algorithms based on the COVID-19 pandemic with experimental and theoretical analysis. The experimental results show that our improved algorithms are effective and efficient. Compared to the exponential cost of the PC algorithm, the time complexity of the PC+ algorithm is reduced to a linear level. Moreover, the accuracies of the PC+ algorithm and DCM algorithm are improved to different degrees; specifically, the accuracy of the PC+ algorithm reaches 91%, much higher than the 33% of the PC algorithm.

Causal Inference for Estimation of Vaccine Effects from Time-to-Event Data

Online causal inference with application to near real‐time post‐market vaccine safety surveillance

Online Causal Inference with Application to Near Real-Time Post-Market Vaccine Safety Surveillance

Causal Inference and Counterfactual Prediction in Machine Learning for Actionable Healthcare

Data Mining Pipeline for COVID-19 Vaccine Safety Analysis Using a Large Electronic Health Record

Methods for the estimation of direct and indirect vaccination effects by combining data from individual‐ and cluster‐randomized trials

Causal inference from observational studies with clustered interference, with application to a cholera vaccine study

Tensor Completion for Causal Inference with Multivariate Longitudinal Data: A Reevaluation of COVID-19 Mandates

Targeted-BEHRT: Deep learning for observational causal inference on longitudinal electronic health records

Improving precision of vaccine efficacy evaluation using immune correlate data in time-to-event models

Efficient nonparametric inference on the effects of stochastic interventions under two-phase sampling, with applications to vaccine efficacy trials

Causal Estimands for Analyses of Averted and Avertible Outcomes due to Infectious Disease Interventions

Causal Effect Estimation and Optimal Dose Suggestions in Mobile Health

A proportional incidence rate model for aggregated data to study the vaccine effectiveness against COVID-19 hospital and ICU admissions

Functional Causal Inference with Time-to-Event Data

Causal Inference When Counterfactuals Depend on the Proportion of All Subjects Exposed

Causal Inference for a Hidden Treatment

Quantifying Efficiency Gains of Innovative Designs of Two-Arm Vaccine Trials for COVID-19 Using an Epidemic Simulation Model

Estimating COVID-19 Vaccine Efficacy via Dynamic Epidemiological Models–A Study of Ten Countries

Prior Knowledge-Based Causal Inference Algorithms and Their Applications for China COVID-19 Analysis

A Bayesian framework for estimating vaccine efficacy per infectious contact