Abstract:During infectious disease outbreaks, humans often base their decision to adhere to an intervention strategy on their personal opinion towards the intervention, perceived risk of infection and intervention effectiveness. However, due to data limitations and inference challenges, infectious disease models usually omit variables that may impact an individual's decision to get vaccinated and their awareness of the intervention's effectiveness of disease control within their social contacts as well as the overall population. We constructed a compartmental, deterministic Susceptible-Exposed-Infectious-Recovered (SEIR) disease model that includes a behavioural function with parameters influencing intervention uptake. The behavioural function accounted for an initial subpopulation opinion towards an intervention, their outbreak information awareness sensitivity and the extent they are swayed by the real-time intervention effectiveness information (at a subpopulation- and population-level) — the selected real-time response construct mimicked a situation of reductions in vaccine uptake due to a negative behavioural response arising from imperfect vaccine protection resulting in breakthrough infections and deaths in vaccinated individuals. Applying the model to vaccination uptake and three human pathogens — pandemic influenza, SARS-CoV-2 and Ebola virus — we explored through model simulation how these intervention adherence decision parameters and behavioural heterogeneity in the population impacted epidemiological outcomes. From our model simulations we found that differences in preference towards outbreak information were pathogen-specific. In other words, in some pathogen systems, different types of outbreak information awareness at different outbreak stages may be more informative to an information-sensitive population and lead to less severe epidemic outcomes. In both behaviourally-homogeneous and behaviourally-heterogeneous populations, pandemic influenza showed patterns distinct from SARS-CoV-2 and Ebola for cumulative epidemiological metrics of interest. Furthermore, there was notable sensitivity in outbreak size under different assumptions regarding the population split in behavioural traits. Outbreak information preference was sensitive to vaccine efficacy, which demonstrates the importance of considering human behaviour during outbreaks in the context of the perceived effectiveness of the intervention. Incorporating behavioural functions that modify infection control intervention adherence into epidemiological models can aid our understanding of adherence dynamics during outbreaks. Ultimately, by parameterising models with what we know about human behaviour towards vaccination (and other infection control interventions) adherence, such models can help assist decision makers during outbreaks. Such progress will be particularly important for emerging infectious diseases when there is initially little information on the disease dynamics and intervention effectiveness.

Causal Estimands for Analyses of Averted and Avertible Outcomes due to Infectious Disease Interventions

Quantifying indirect and direct vaccination effects arising in the SIR model

Identification of causal intervention effects under contagion

Inverse probability weighted estimators of vaccine effects accommodating partial interference and censoring

Causal inference from observational studies with clustered interference, with application to a cholera vaccine study

Comparing modelling approaches for the estimation of government intervention effects in COVID-19: Impact of voluntary behavior changes

Estimating community-wide indirect effects of influenza vaccination: triangulation using mathematical models and bias analysis

Unifying human infectious disease models and real-time awareness of population- and subpopulation-level intervention effectiveness

Evaluating the direct effect of vaccination and non-pharmaceutical interventions during the COVID-19 pandemic in Europe

Assessing effects of cholera vaccination in the presence of interference

Impact of Modelling Approach on the Estimation of Government Intervention Effects in COVID-19

A counterfactual analysis quantifying the COVID-19 vaccination impact in Sweden

When should lockdown be implemented? Devising cost-effective strategies for managing epidemics amid vaccine uncertainty

Estimating the impact of non-pharmaceutical interventions and vaccination on the progress of the COVID-19 epidemic in Mexico: a mathematical approach

COVID-19 and the difficulty of inferring epidemiological parameters from clinical data

Masks and COVID-19: a causal framework for imputing value to public-health interventions

Estimates of SARS-COV-2 Behavior in the COVID-19 Crisis: Addressing Sample-Selection Bias for Public Health Applications

Evaluating the Impact of Vaccine Hesitancy on the Allocation of Vital Resources During COVID-19 Pandemic

Cost–benefit analysis of the COVID-19 vaccination model incorporating different infectivity reductions

The impact of vaccination on COVID-19 outbreaks in the United States