Abstract:Background Pencil beam scanning (PBS) proton therapy for moving targets is known to be impacted by interplay effects between the scanning beam and organ motion. While respiratory motion in the thoracic region is the major cause for organ motion, interplay effects depend on the delivery characteristics of proton accelerators. Purpose To evaluate the impact of different types of PBS proton accelerators and spot sizes on interplay effects, mitigations, and plan quality for Stereotactic Body Radiation Therapy (SBRT) treatment of non‐small cell lung cancer (NSCLC). Methods Twenty NSCLC patients treated with photon SBRT were selected to represent varying tumor volumes and respiratory motion amplitudes (median: 0.6 cm with abdominal compression) for this retrospective study. For each patient, plans were created using: (1) cyclotron‐generated proton beams (CPB) with spot sizes of σ = 2.7–7.0 mm; (2) linear accelerator proton beams (LPB) (σ = 2.9–5.5 mm); and (3) linear accelerator proton minibeams (LPMB) (σ = 0.9–3.9 mm). The energy switching time is one second for CPB, and 0.005 s for LPMB and LPB. Plans were robustly optimized on the gross tumor volume (GTV) using each individual phase of four‐dimensional computed tomography (4DCT) scans. Initially, single‐field optimization (SFO) plans were evaluated; if the plan quality did not meet the dosimetric requirement, multi‐field optimization (MFO) was used. MFO plans were created for all patients for comparisons. For each patient, all plans were normalized to have the same dose received by 99% of the GTV. Interplay effects were evaluated by computing the dose on 10 breathing phases, based on the spot distribution. Volumetric repainting (VR) was performed 2–6 times for each plan. We compared volume receiving 100% of the prescribed dose (V100%RX) of the GTV, and normal lung V20Gy. Results Twelve of 20 plans can be optimized sufficiently with SFO. SFO plans were less sensitive to the interplay effect compared to MFO plans in terms of target coverage for both LPB and LPMB. The following comparisons showed results utilizing the MFO technique. In the interplay evaluation without repainting, the mean V100%RX of the GTV were 99.42 ± 0.6%, 97.52 ± 3.9%, and 94.49 ± 7.3% for CPB, LPB, and LPMB plans, respectively. Following VR (2 × for CPB; 3 × for LPB; 5 × for LPMB), V100%RX of the GTV were improved (on average) by 0.13%, 1.84%, and 4.63%, respectively, achieving the acceptance criteria of V100%RX > 95%. Because of fast energy switch in linear accelerator proton machines, the delivery time for VR plans was the lowest for LPB plans, while delivery time for LPMB was on average 1 min longer than CPB plans. The advantage of small spot machines was better sparing in normal lung V20Gy, even when VR was applied. Conclusion In the absence of repainting, proton machines with large spot sizes generated more robust plans against interplay effects. The number of VR increased with decreasing spot sizes to achieve the acceptance criteria. VR improved the plan robustness against interplay effects for modalities with small spot sizes and fast energy changes, preserving the low dose sparing aspect of the LPMB, even when motion is included.

Development of porous structure for broadening Bragg-peak in scanning carbon-ion radiotherapy: Monte Carlo simulation and experimental validation

Biophysical characterization of collimated and uncollimated fields in pencil beam scanning proton therapy

Conformal Dose Modulator for Proton Beam Therapy Part 1: A Simulation Study

Modelling small block aperture in an in-house developed GPU-accelerated Monte Carlo-based dose engine for pencil beam scanning proton therapy

Challenges for the Implementation of Primary Standard Dosimetry in Proton Minibeam Radiation Therapy

Practical biological spread-out Bragg peak design of carbon beam

Beam quality improvement in the later stage of radiation pressure acceleration

Prompt Gamma Imaging with a Multi-Knife-edge Slit Collimator for Large FOV Monitoring of Scanned Proton Pencil Beams

3D Proton Bragg Peak Visualization and Spot Shape Measurement with Polymer Gel Dosimeters

Utilizing collimated aperture with proton pencil beam scanning (PBS) for stereotactic radiotherapy

Implementation of novel measurement-based patient-specific QA for pencil beam scanning proton FLASH radiotherapy

The influence of beam delivery uncertainty on dose uniformity and penumbra for pencil beam scanning in carbon-ion radiotherapy

Flat-panel imager energy-dependent proton radiography for a proton pencil-beam scanning system

Long-term stability of a PTW 34070 large-area parallel ionization chamber in clinical proton scanning beams

An improved beam splitting method for intensity modulated proton therapy

Modelling beam transport and biological effectiveness to develop treatment planning for ion beam radiotherapy

Novel Bragg peak characterization method using proton flux measurements on plastic scintillators

High spatiotemporal resolution scintillation imaging of pulsed pencil beam scanning proton beams produced by a gantry‐mounted synchrocyclotron

Cyclotron and linear accelerator generated scanning proton beams for lung cancer SBRT: Interplay effects and mitigations

Beam specific planning target volumes incorporating 4DCT for pencil beam scanning proton therapy of thoracic tumors

Feasibility Study of Hybrid Inverse Planning with Transmission Beams and Single-energy Spread-out Bragg Peaks for Proton Flash Radiotherapy