Abstract:Context: Integrated rice-aquatic animals culture systems (RACSs) are of interest in sustainability research because they have been found to host diverse species and there is potential for positive synergistic effects be-tween the plant (rice) and aquatic animal culture. However, their effect on soil fertility, rice productivity, and greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions, as well as the associations among them, remain unclear. Objectives: A meta-analysis was conducted to systematically evaluate the sustainability of RACSs from the perspective of "rice productivity-GHG emissions-soil fertility" and their associations and to clarify how envi-ronmental factors and fertilizer-management practices affect responses of rice yield and GHG emissions to RACSs.Methods: We conducted a meta-analysis of 1807 paired observations collected from 78 published papers covering four countries that compared soil fertility, rice yield, and GHG emissions in a conventional rice monoculture system (CRMS) and in a RACS.Results: Overall, the RACSs improved soil structure (soil bulk density declined by 5.8 % and total and capillary porosity increased by 6.4 % and 5.7 %, respectively), increased soil organic carbon (C, 7.9 %) and nitrogen (N, 6.6 %) storage, and reduced CH4 (9.2 %) and N2O (4.5 %) emissions; rice yield were little higher (by 2.0 %) than that of the CRMS. However, the effects varied under different RACS modes, environmental factors, and fertilizer-management practices. For instance, compared to CRMS, yields were 4.1 % higher in the rice-duck mode, 3.9 % lower in the rice-crayfish mode, and the no significantly change in the rice-fish system. The effects on GHG emissions and soil fertility were more pronounced in the rice-duck and rice-crayfish modes than in the rice-fish mode. Furthermore, paddy soils with low fertility (lower soil organic C and N) and less nutrient (nitrogen and phosphorus) input provide a higher rice yield and lower GHG emissions under RACSs.Conclusions: Overall, the RACSs stabilized rice productivity and reduced GHG emissions by improving the soil structure and increasing soil C and N sequestration; however, the effects varied by different RACS modes, initial soil properties, fertilizer input rate, and climate conditions. As such, environmental factors and nutrient man-agement should be considered when designing and deciding what type of RACSs to employ. Our results also highlight the great potential of RACSs in the development of sustainable agriculture practices in the context of climate change.Implications: Future research and applications should consider the response of RACSs to climate and environ-mental factors and fertilizer-management practices, to achieve greater production and environmental benefits.

Co-culture of rice and aquatic animals mitigates greenhouse gas emissions from rice paddies

Higher Food Yields and Lower Greenhouse Gas Emissions from Aquaculture Ponds with High-Stalk Rice Planted.

How does rice-animal co-culture system affect rice yield and greenhouse gas? A meta-analysis

Integrated rice-aquatic animals culture systems promote the sustainable development of agriculture by improving soil fertility and reducing greenhouse gas emissions

Appropriately Delayed Flooding Before Rice Transplanting Increases Net Ecosystem Economic Benefit in the Winter Green Manure-Rice Rotation System

Application of controlled-release urea to maintain rice yield and mitigate greenhouse gas emissions of rice–crayfish coculture field

Effects of straw returning and feeding on greenhouse gas emissions from integrated rice-crayfish farming in Jianghan Plain, China

Integrated Rice-Crayfish Farming System Does Not Mitigate the Global Warming Potential During Rice Season.

Lower methane and nitrous oxide emissions from rice-aquaculture co-culture systems than from rice paddies in southeast China,

Water-saving Ground Cover Rice Production System Reduces Net Greenhouse Gas Fluxes in an Annual Rice-Based Cropping System

Appropriate Irrigation and Fertilization Regime Restrain Indigenous Soil Key Ammonia-Oxidizing Archaeal and Bacterial Consortia to Mitigate Greenhouse Gas Emissions

Ecological rice-cropping systems mitigate global warming – A meta-analysis

Solutions to Neutralize Greenhouse Gas Emissions of the Rice Value Chain-a Case Study in China

Co-culture of Rice and Aquatic Animals: an Integrated System to Achieve Production and Environmental Sustainability

Elevated CO2 does not necessarily enhance greenhouse gas emissions from rice paddies

Rice‐animal Co‐culture Systems Benefit Global Sustainable Intensification

Integrating Agronomic Practices to Reduce Greenhouse Gas Emissions While Increasing the Economic Return in a Rice-Based Cropping System

Elevated [CO2] Reduces CH4 Emissions from Rice Paddies under in Situ Straw Incorporation

Annual greenhouse gas emissions from a rice paddy with different water-nitrogen management strategies in Central China

Regulation and Mechanism of Greenhouse Gas Emissions of Circular Agriculture Ecosystem of Planting and Breeding in Paddy

Greenhouse gas emissions and mitigation in rice agriculture