Abstract:Finding the right balance of quality and quantity can be important, and it is essential that project quality does not drop below the level where important main conclusions are missed or misstated. We use knock-out and over-expression studies as a simplification to test recovery of a known causal gene in RNA-Seq cell line experiments. When single-end RNA-Seq reads are aligned with STAR and quantified with htseq-count, we found potential value in testing the use of the Generalized Linear Model (GLM) implementation of edgeR with robust dispersion estimation more frequently for either single-variate or multi-variate 2-group comparisons (with the possibility of defining criteria less stringent than |fold-change| > 1.5 and FDR < 0.05). When considering a limited number of patient sample comparisons with larger sample size, there might be some decreased variability between methods (except for DESeq1). However, at the same time, the ranking of the gene identified using immunohistochemistry (for ER/PR/HER2 in breast cancer samples from The Cancer Genome Atlas) showed as possible shift in performance compared to the cell line comparisons, potentially highlighting utility for standard statistical tests and/or limma-based analysis with larger sample sizes. If this continues to be true in additional studies and comparisons, then that could be consistent with the possibility that it may be important to allocate time for potential methods troubleshooting for genomics projects. Analysis of public data presented in this study does not consider all experimental designs, and presentation of downstream analysis is limited. So, any estimate from this simplification would be an underestimation of the true need for some methods testing for every project. Additionally, this set of independent cell line experiments has a limitation in being able to determine the frequency of missing a highly important gene if the problem is rare (such as 10% or lower). For example, if there was an assumption that only one method can be tested for “initial” analysis, then it is not completely clear to the extent that using edgeR-robust might perform better than DESeq2 in the cell line experiments. Importantly, we do not wish to cause undue concern, and we believe that it should often be possible to define a gene expression differential expression workflow that is suitable for some purposes for many samples. Nevertheless, at the same time, we provide a variety of measures that we believe emphasize the need to critically assess every individual project and maximize confidence in published results.

Testing the Significance of Ranked Gene Sets in Genome-Wide Transcriptome Profiling Data Using Weighted Rank Correlation Statistics

Gene Set linkage analysis: a tool for interpreting the overall functional impacts of observed transcriptomic changes

Finding significant gene sets with weighted distribution of gene expression

Correlating gene expression levels with transcription factor binding sites facilitates identification of key transcription factors from transcriptome data

A Rank Sum Test Method for Informative Gene Discovery.

Application of the Gini correlation coefficient to infer regulatory relationships in transcriptome analysis.

Considering Dependencies Amongst Genes Helps to Adjust the Significance Rank of DEGs

Rank-in: Enabling Integrative Analysis Across Microarray and RNA-seq for Cancer

On testing the significance of sets of genes

A novel significance score for gene selection and ranking

Disease-related Gene Expression Analysis Using an Ensemble Statistical Test Method

Gene Ranking of RNA-Seq Data Via Discriminant Non-Negative Matrix Factorization

scGIR: deciphering cellular heterogeneity via gene ranking in single-cell weighted gene correlation networks

Toward Comprehensive Functional Analysis of Gene Lists Weighted by Gene Essentiality Scores.

Assessment of Gene Set Enrichment Analysis using curated RNA-seq-based benchmarks

Learning Gene Regulatory Networks from Gene Expression Data Using Weighted Consensus.

Systematical Detection Of Significant Genes In Microarray Data By Incorporating Gene Interaction Relationship In Biological Systems

Differential Regulation Enrichment Analysis Via the Integration of Transcriptional Regulatory Network and Gene Expression Data.

Critical Differential Expression Assessment for Individual Bulk RNA-Seq Projects

Identifying Differentially Expressed Genes from Cross-Site Integrated Data Based on Relative Expression Orderings.

Ranking analysis for identifying differentially expressed genes.