From Centre to Suburbs: Investigating How Transit Maps Streamline Residents' Spatial Representations
Florian Leprévost Elise Grison Archana Prabhakar Simon Lhuillier Simone Morgagni 1 Direction de la Recherche,SNCF,La Plaine Saint-Denis,France2 LaPEA,Université Paris Cité & Université Gustave Eiffel,Versailles,FranceFlorian Leprévost earned his Master's degree in Cognitive Science from ENS-PSL in 2021 and collaborates with SNCF Research Department,studying human cognition and its applications in transportation systems. His work focuses on improving passenger comfort and security aboard trains and mass transit networks,and understanding how travel decisions are made.Archana Prabhakar is a final year PhD student at the LAPEA laboratory (Université Paris Cité & Université Gustave Eiffel). Within the 'Experience,Behaviour & Cognition' research group at The French National Railway Company (SNCF) she studies the use of smartphone mobility assistants as tools for passenger flow regulation in mass transit. Her research interests include decision making,spatial cognition,and public transport demand management.Simon Lhuillier is a research engineer in experimental psychology at the Université Gustave Eiffel in Versailles,France. His research focuses mainly on the mental representation of space-time in healthy humans,studying how errors in the processing of distances or durations can provide information about the functional mechanisms of cognition.Elise Grison completed a PhD in Cognitive Psychology at the Université Sorbonne Paris Cité and IFSTTAR in 2015. Her work has mainly focused on spatial cognition,especially on wayfinding processes and route choice. She has contributed to the field of schematic mapping by analysing how people gaze when they plan a route. She also has developed work on route planning strategies and bias using schematic maps since she joined SNCF in 2020.Simone Morgagni is currently Head of the 'Experience,Behaviour & Cognition' research group,the research department at SNCF with expertise in semiotics,transit,and cognitive sciences. He implements research programs and collaborations to promote a renewed and human-centred vision of mobility.
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/00087041.2024.2335605
2024-07-27
The Cartographic Journal
Abstract:Representations we hold of our cities are acquired not just through direct spatial experience, but also through maps, potentially including schematic maps like transit maps. Following Beck's pioneering work, transit maps include practical schematic modifications, with scale changes that usually result in an expansion of central regions while compressing the peripheries. But it is not yet clear whether such a distortion exists in the minds of residents, and whether it could be due to cognitive biases, or to the transit maps' influence. Here, after showing that the centre–periphery segmentation is stronger in Parisians' minds than in Londoners', we investigated reference and segmentation effects in the way residents placed landmarks on a blank background. Those effects indeed explained part of centre–periphery distortions that were found, but some angular and scale changes could still only be explained by transit maps, confirming they indeed streamline residents' spatial representations.
geography