Design and Usability of an Open-Source, Low-Cost Flexible Laryngoscope for Resource-Limited Settings
Yashes Srinivasan,David Shamritsky,Asmita Bhatta,Ellaine Chou,Trang Pham,Yashi Sanghvi,Lily Woolf,Michael Zhang,Eseosa Odigie,Clemence Chidziva,Erasmus Muganda,Priscilla Zimani,Newton de Faria,Anaïs Rameau
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1001/jamaoto.2024.0063
2024-03-07
JAMA Otolaryngology–Head & Neck Surgery
Abstract:Importance Endoscopes are paramount to the practice of otolaryngology. To provide physicians in low-middle–income countries with adequate tools to treat otolaryngologic problems, it is necessary to create a low-cost sustainable option. Objective To describe the design and usability of an open-source, low-cost flexible laryngoscope that addresses the lack of affordable and accessible methods for otolaryngologic visualization in resource-limited settings. Design, Setting, and Participants This quality improvement study used a mixed-methods approach, including a technical description of device design as well as quantitative and qualitative survey evaluation of device usability. Engineering involved device design, sourcing or manufacturing individual components, fabricating a prototype, and iterative testing. Key assumptions and needs for the device were identified in collaboration with otolaryngologists in Zimbabwe, and designed and simulated by biomedical engineers in a US university laboratory. Board-certified otolaryngologists at a single US university hospital trialed a completed prototype on simulated airways between May 2023 and June 2023. Main Outcomes and Measures Technical details on the design of the device are provided. Otolaryngologist gave feedback on device characteristics, maneuverability, and visualization using the System Usability Scale, a customized Likert-scale questionnaire (5-point scale), and semistructured interviews. Results A functional prototype meeting requirements was completed consisting of a distal-chip camera, spring bending tip, handle housing the control mechanism and electronics, and flexible polyether block amide–coated silicone sheath housing the camera and control wires; an external monitor provided real-time visualization and ability to store data. A total of 14 otolaryngologists participated in the device review. The mean (SD) System Usability Scale score was 88.93 (10.08), suggesting excellent usability. The device was rated highly for ease of set up, physical attributes, image quality, and functionality. Conclusions and Relevance This quality improvement study described the design of a novel open-source low-cost flexible laryngoscope that external review with otolaryngologists suggests was usable and feasible in various resource-limited environments. Future work is needed to translate the model into a clinical setting.
surgery,otorhinolaryngology