Abstract:Glyphosate was classified as a probable human carcinogen (Group 2A) by the International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC) partially due to strong mechanistic evidence in 2015. Since then, numerous studies of glyphosate and its formulations (GBF) have emerged. These studies can be evaluated for cancer hazard identification with the newly described ten key characteristics (KC) of carcinogens approach. Our objective was to assess all in vivo, ex vivo, and in vitro mechanistic studies of human and experimental animals (mammals) that compared exposure to glyphosate/GBF with low/no exposure counterparts for evidence of the ten KCs. A protocol with our methods adhering to PRISMA guidelines was registered a priori (INPLASY202180045). Two blinded reviewers screened all in vivo, ex vivo, and in vitro studies of glyphosate/GBF exposure in humans/mammals reporting any KC-related outcome available in PubMed before August 2021. Studies that met inclusion criteria underwent data extraction conducted in duplicate for each KC outcome reported along with key aspects of internal/external validity, results, and reference information. These data were used to construct a matrix that was subsequently analyzed in the program R to conduct strength of evidence and quality assessments. Of the 2537 articles screened, 175 articles met inclusion criteria, from which we extracted >50,000 data points related to KC outcomes. Data analysis revealed strong evidence for KC2, KC4, KC5, KC6, KC8, limited evidence for KC1 and KC3, and inadequate evidence for KC7, KC9, and KC10. Notably, our in-depth quality analyses of genotoxicity (KC2) and endocrine disruption (KC8) revealed strong and consistent positive findings. For KC2, we found: 1) studies conducted in humans and human cells provided stronger positive evidence than counterpart animal models; 2) GBF elicited a stronger effect in both human and animal systems when compared to glyphosate alone; and 3) the highest quality studies in humans and human cells consistently revealed strong evidence of genotoxicity. Our analysis of KC8 indicated that glyphosate's ability to modulate hormone levels and estrogen receptor activity is sensitive to both exposure concentration and formulation. The modulations observed provide clear evidence that glyphosate interacts with receptors, alters receptor activation, and modulates the levels and effects of endogenous ligands (including hormones). Our findings strengthen the mechanistic evidence that glyphosate is a probable human carcinogen and provide biological plausibility for previously reported cancer associations in humans, such as non-Hodgkin lymphoma. We identified potential molecular interactions and subsequent key events that were used to generate a probable pathway to lymphomagenesis.

Risk assessment of carcinogens in food

Retrospective analysis of carcinogenicity assessments within FDA-notified GRAS determinations

Carcinogenic Food Contaminants

Genotoxicity testing approaches for the safety assessment of substances used in food contact materials prior to their authorization in the European Union

In Silico Approaches In Carcinogenicity Hazard Assessment: Current Status and Future Needs

A comprehensive view on mechanistic approaches for cancer risk assessment of non-genotoxic agrochemicals

Assessing chemical carcinogenicity: hazard identification, classification, and risk assessment. Insight from a Toxicology Forum state-of-the-science workshop

Current risk assessment approaches in different countries

Towards a mechanism-based approach for the prediction of nongenotoxic carcinogenic potential of agrochemicals

A simple approach to assess the cancer risk of occupational exposure to genotoxic drugs in healthcare settings

Food-Borne Chemical Carcinogens and the Evidence for Human Cancer Risk

Potential mammary carcinogens used in food contact articles: implications for policy, enforcement, and prevention

Analytical Chemistry, Formation, Mitigation, and Risk Assessment of Polycyclic Aromatic Hydrocarbons: from Food Processing to in Vivo Metabolic Transformation

Approaches to risk assessment for macronutrients and amino acids

The comprehensive prediction of carcinogenic potency and tumorigenic dose (TD 50 ) for two problematic N-nitrosamines in food: NMAMPA and NMAMBA using toxicology in silico methods

Mapping the key characteristics of carcinogens for glyphosate and its formulations: A systematic review

Computational framework for identifying and evaluating mutagenic and xenoestrogenic potential of food additives

Glyphosate toxicity and carcinogenicity: a review of the scientific basis of the European Union assessment and its differences with IARC

A brief history of risk assessment for agrochemicals

The use of toxicologic data in mechanistic risk assessment: 1,3-butadiene as a case study

Current risk assessment approaches for environmental and food and feed safety assessment