Engineering is evolution: a perspective on design processes to engineer biology

Simeon D. Castle,Michiel Stock,Thomas E. Gorochowski

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-024-48000-1

IF: 16.6

2024-04-30

Nature Communications

Abstract:Careful consideration of how we approach design is crucial to all areas of biotechnology. However, choosing or developing an effective design methodology is not always easy as biology, unlike most areas of engineering, is able to adapt and evolve. Here, we put forward that design and evolution follow a similar cyclic process and therefore all design methods, including traditional design, directed evolution, and even random trial and error, exist within an evolutionary design spectrum. This contrasts with conventional views that often place these methods at odds and provides a valuable framework for unifying engineering approaches for challenging biological design problems.

multidisciplinary sciences

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is how to select or develop effective design methods in biological engineering to overcome the challenges brought by the complexity and uncertainty of biological systems. Specifically, the paper explores the similarities between design and evolution and proposes that all design methods, including traditional design, directed evolution, and random trial - and - error, exist in an "evolutionary design spectrum". This view is different from the traditional view, which usually opposes these methods. Through this framework, the paper aims to provide a unified methodology for solving complex biological design problems.

The paper emphasizes that synthetic biology aims to apply engineering principles and design processes to create biological systems with new functions. However, due to the complexity of biological systems, the existing bio - engineering paradigms limit our engineering capabilities for organisms without considering the evolutionary history and potential evolutionary future of organisms. Therefore, a new engineering approach is needed, which is based on different philosophical assumptions and incorporates change, uncertainty, emergence, and complexity.

In addition, the paper also proposes the concept that "bio - engineering is meta - engineering", that is, bio - engineers not only design simple artifacts but also design systems that can self - design, which requires bio - engineers to operate at a higher level of abstraction. By analogizing the design process to the development of photography, the paper expounds how the design process has changed from directly manipulating images to constructing image - generation systems, thus applying human skills and creativity to a higher level of abstraction.

Overall, the paper attempts to provide a new perspective and methodological framework for the engineering design of biological systems by redefining the design process and the application of engineering principles.