Development and Validation of the Overall Fidelity Enactment Scale for Complex Interventions (OFES-CI)
Ginsburg,L.,Hoben,M.,Berta,W.,Doupe,M.,Estabrooks,C.,Norton,P.,Reid,C.,Geerts,A.,Wagg,A.
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2023.02.01.23285328
2023-02-03
MedRxiv
Abstract:Background. Assessing fidelity in complex interventions is important. Ignoring it increases the risk of discarding potentially effective interventions that failed to work because they were not implemented as intended or, accepting ineffective interventions whose effects were brought about by factors other than the intervention. Unlike simple interventions, fidelity assessment in complex interventions is underexplored and not straightforward. Adapting the evaluative approach used in Objective Structured Clinical Exams (OSCEs), we describe the development and validation of an easy to use, objective approach to fidelity assessment (the Overall Fidelity Enactment Scale for use in complex interventions: OFES-CI). Methods. We developed the OFES-CI and assessed its accuracy using secondary data collected as part of the process evaluation of the SCOPE intervention. Specifically, we compared the OFES-CI ratings obtained from trained study observers during SCOPE intervention workshops to more detailed and comprehensive qualitative fidelity enactment data collected between and during the same workshops (our gold standard). Results. The OFES-CI demonstrates acceptable reliability against our gold standard assessment approach and addresses the practicality problem in fidelity assessment by virtue of its suitable implementation qualities (acceptability, ease of completion, low burden, low training requirements). It can be easily adapted to assess enactment of a variety of complex interventions. Conclusions. Global ratings approaches validated in the context of assessing clinician competence in OSCEs provide a novel, practical and underexplored opportunity to assess fidelity enactment in complex trials. Given important questions that are increasingly being asked regarding evaluation of complex pragmatic interventions, the proposed approach to fidelity assessment, if incorporated into trial evaluation, stands to provide valuable insights not only into why an intervention may succeed or fail but also how we might carry out adaptations of complex interventions when they are needed.