Abstract:Background: Implementation fidelity assesses the degree to which an intervention is delivered as it should be. Fidelity helps to determine if the outcome(s) of an intervention are attributed to the intervention itself or to a failure of its implementation. Little is known about how fidelity impacts the intended outcome(s) and what elements or moderators can affect the fidelity trajectory over time. We exemplify the meaning of implementation fidelity with INTERCARE, a nurse-led care model that was implemented in eleven Swiss nursing homes (NHs) and showed effectiveness in reducing unplanned hospital transfers. INTERCARE comprises six core elements, including advance care planning and tools to support inter- and interprofessional communication, which were introduced with carefully developed implementation strategies. Methods: A mixed-methods convergent/triangulation design was used to investigate the influence of implementation fidelity on unplanned transfers. A fidelity questionnaire measuring the degree of fidelity to INTERCARE's core components was fielded at four time points in the participating NHs. Two-monthly meetings were conducted with NHs (September 2018-January 2020) and structured notes were used to determine moderators affecting fidelity (e.g., participant responsiveness). We used the fidelity scores and generalized linear mixed models to analyze the quantitative data. The Framework method was used for the qualitative analysis. The quantitative and qualitative findings were integrated using triangulation. Results: A higher overall fidelity score showed a decreasing rate of unplanned hospital transfers post-intervention (OR: 0.65 (CI = 0.43-0.99), p = 0.047). A higher fidelity score to advance care planning was associated with lower unplanned transfers (OR = 0.24 (CI 0.13-0.44), p = < 0.001) and a lower fidelity score for communication tools (e.g., ISBAR) to higher rates in unplanned transfers (OR = 1.69 (CI 1.30-2.19), p = < 0.003). In-house physicians with a collaborative approach and staff's perceived need for nurses working in extended roles, were important moderators to achieve and sustain high fidelity. Conclusion: Implementation fidelity is challenging to measure and report, especially in complex interventions, yet is crucial to better understand how such interventions may be tailored for scale-up. This study provides both a detailed description of how fidelity can be measured and which ingredients highly contributed to reducing unplanned NH transfers. Trial registration: The INTERCARE study was registered at clinicaltrials.gov Protocol Record NCT03590470.

Caregiver Intervention Implementation Fidelity: An Empirical Investigation of a Multidimensional Model

Examining fidelity reporting within studies of foundational reading interventions for elementary students with or at risk for dyslexia

A Longitudinal Analysis of Trajectories and Predictors of Fidelity Using the SafeCare Parenting Model

Considering the implementation research-to-practice gap: An experimental evaluation of intervention-general methods for assessing and supporting intervention fidelity through coaching

The Case for Assessing and Reporting on Facilitator Fidelity: Introducing the Fidelity of Implementation in Parenting Programs Guideline

Teaching Parents Enhanced Milieu Teaching With Words and Signs Using the Teach-Model-Coach-Review Model

Fidelity of implementation of activity-based intervention in daycare

Preschool Teachers’ Implementation Fidelity When Using a Technology-Mediated Language and Literacy Intervention

Factors Associated With Caregiver Attendance in Implementation of Multiple Evidence-Based Practices in Youth Mental Health Services

Reading Intervention in Middle and High Schools: Implementation Fidelity, Teacher Efficacy, and Student Achievement

Adaptations and early adoption of a family caregiver intervention in the Veterans Affairs Health Care System: A multimethod pragmatic approach for national scaling

Evaluating the implementation fidelity to a successful nurse-led model (INTERCARE) which reduced nursing home unplanned hospitalisations

Fidelity to the ACT SMART Toolkit: an instrumental case study of implementation strategy fidelity

Fostering implementation of health services research findings into practice: a consolidated framework for advancing implementation science

Implementation outcomes from a multi-site stepped wedge cluster randomized family caregiver skills training trial

Relationship Between Implementation of Collaborative Strategic Reading and Student Outcomes for Adolescents With Disabilities

Implementing and Evaluating Manualized Interventions in U.S. Organizations Serving Youth with Foster Care Experience: Lessons Learned from the Field

Measuring fidelity of delivery of the Community Occupational Therapy in Dementia-UK intervention

Defining, Conceptualizing, and Measuring Fidelity of Implementation and Its Relationship to Outcomes in K–12 Curriculum Intervention Research

Fidelity Assessment in Community Programs: An Approach to Validating Simplified Methodology

Assessing fidelity to family-based treatment: an exploratory examination of expert, therapist, parent, and peer ratings