Abstract:Under a multinormal distribution with an arbitrary unknown covariance matrix, the main purpose of this paper is to propose a framework to achieve the goal of reconciliation of Bayesian, frequentist, and Fisher's reporting $p$-values, Neyman-Pearson's optimal theory and Wald's decision theory for the problems of testing mean against restricted alternatives (closed convex cones). To proceed, the tests constructed via the likelihood ratio (LR) and the union-intersection (UI) principles are studied. For the problems of testing against restricted alternatives, first, we show that the LRT and the UIT are not the proper Bayes tests, however, they are shown to be the integrated LRT and the integrated UIT, respectively. For the problem of testing against the positive orthant space alternative, both the null distributions of the LRT and the UIT depend on the unknown nuisance covariance matrix. Hence we have difficulty adopting Fisher's approach to reporting $p$-values. On the other hand, according to the definition of the level of significance, both the LRT and the UIT are shown to be power-dominated by the corresponding LRT and UIT for testing against the half-space alternative, respectively. Hence, both the LRT and the UIT are $\alpha$-inadmissible, these results are against the common statistical sense. Neither Fisher's approach of reporting $p$-values alone nor Neyman-Pearson's optimal theory for power function alone is a satisfactory criterion for evaluating the performance of tests. Wald's decision theory via $d$-admissibility may shed light on resolving these challenging issues of imposing the balance between type 1 error and power.

On testing the equality of latent roots of scatter matrices under ellipticity

Optimal rank-based testing for principal components

Testing High-dimensional Covariance Matrices under the Elliptical Distribution and Beyond

A New Statistic for Testing Covariance Equality in High-Dimensional Gaussian Low-Rank Models

Testing equality of spectral densities using randomization techniques

Testing the equality of multivariate means when $p>n$ by combining the Hoteling and Simes tests

Rank-based optimal tests of the adequacy of an elliptic VARMA model

Global Testing under the Sparse Alternatives for Single Index Models

On testing the equality of high dimensional mean vectors with unequal covariance matrices

Testing independence in high dimensions with sums of rank correlations

Testing Elliptical Models in High Dimensions

Higher-Order Asymptotics and Its Application to Testing the Equality of the Examinee Ability Over Two Sets of Items

Exact and efficient multivariate two-sample tests through generalized linear rank statistics

Log-Rank-Type Tests for Equality of Distributions in High-Dimensional Spaces.

Towards a theory for testing statistical hypothesis: Multivariate mean with nuisance covariance matrix

Tests for Large-Dimensional Shape Matrices via Tyler's M Estimators

Minimax rate of testing in sparse linear regression

Testing Equality of Spectral Density Operators for Functional Processes

Tests for Large-Dimensional Shape Matrices Via Tyler’s M Estimators

Testing equality between several populations covariance operators