Abstract:This work explores engineering ethics empirically in a “developing world” context through a framework of care ethics. Care ethics, a.k.a., the ethic(s) of care, is particularly suitable for the “developing world” context because it helps draw attention to imbalances of power (e.g., inequality, differential opportunity, and limitations on autonomy) that are often neglected by other ethical frameworks. In this work, we selected one element of care ethics (responsibility) and operationalized it in several ways: the language of responsibility; notions of paternalism; and awareness of key, influencing stakeholders. These lenses were developed and refined iteratively by employing them in case study analyses of two design project reports written by teams of senior undergraduate engineering students. Our interpretive analysis of this data outlined significant differences in care-ethical responsibility as viewed through each lens. For example, one group demonstrated little paternalism and considered several key, influencing stakeholders in their report, while the other group employed a more paternalistic approach and considered fewer key influencing stakeholders. In the interest of broadening ethical awareness in engineering, the findings and outcomes of this work can be used by educators to inform the design of course materials, exercises, and evaluation/grading criteria, such as by adapting these lenses for use in self-and/or peer-assessment. This work can also be used by researchers interested in care ethics and/or engineering student responses to issues of humanitarian or social justice nature to inform interview question and survey item design. Finally, this work contributes to the discourse of engineering ethics by developing and applying an ethical framework from the wider literature that has not received much attention in engineering ethics to date.

The virtuous, the caring, and the free: ethical theory to understand the ethics of the teacher as a role model in engineering education

A Study on the Role Morality Conflict of Engineers

Status Quo and Prospects of Engineering Ethics

Training responsible engineers. Phronesis and the role of virtues in teaching engineering ethics

Engineering Student’s Ethical Awareness and Behavior: A New Motivational Model

Virtue Ethics, Positive Psychology, and a New Model of Science and Engineering Ethics Education

Connecting to the Heart: Teaching Value-Based Professional Ethics

Student-inspired activities for the teaching and learning of engineering ethics

Enhancing Engineering Ethics: Role Ethics and Corporate Social Responsibility

Teaching Virtue: Pedagogical Implications of Moral Psychology

What do we teach to engineering students: embedded ethics, morality, and politics

Professional Virtue and Professional Self-Awareness: A Case Study in Engineering Ethics

Ethics in Engineering Students' Design Considerations: Case Studies of Elec- tric Power Systems for the "Developing World"

Explore the Intrinsic Value and Practical Development of Engineering Ethical Responsibility

Operationalizing Ethical Becoming as a Theoretical Framework for Teaching Engineering Design Ethics

The teacher educator as a role model

Ethics as an outcome of out-of-class engagement across diverse groups of engineering students

Autonomous Driving Ethics Case Study for Engineering Ethics Education

Practical ethical frameworks for civil engineering and environmental systems

A Fundamental Study on Ethics of Teaching

Engineer’s ethics formation by teaching foreign language: sociocultural aspect