Are Poles stuck in overeducation? Individual dynamics of educational mismatch in Poland

Jan Aleksander Baran

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/1406099x.2024.2340401

2024-04-26

Baltic Journal of Economics

Abstract:The paper investigates the short-run job mobility of educationally mismatched workers, examining the validity of the Sicherman-Galor hypothesis, which predicts that overeducation is a temporary condition from a worker's perspective associated with higher upward occupational and wage mobility. The study uses data from the Polish Labour Force Survey, investigating yearly changes in employment status, occupation, and wages. The results show that overeducated workers are more likely to remain employed compared to their properly matched colleagues. Both overeducated and undereducated workers tend to move towards jobs for which they are better matched. However, the rate of this adjustment is very low, contradicting the Sicherman-Galor hypothesis. On the other hand, overeducated workers, but mostly prime-aged ones, are found to experience faster wage growth compared to properly matched individuals, aligning with the Sicherman-Galor hypothesis. The higher wage growth of overeducated workers can be partially attributed to workers improving their match status over time.

economics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### The Problem the Paper Attempts to Solve

The paper aims to explore the dynamic changes in the phenomenon of overeducation in the Polish labor market and to verify the validity of the Sicherman-Galor hypothesis. The Sicherman-Galor hypothesis posits that overeducation is a temporary state, and in the long run, overeducated workers will gradually find jobs that better match their education level, thereby achieving higher occupational status and wages.

Specifically, the paper investigates the following aspects:
1. **Employment Stability**: Whether overeducated workers are more likely to remain employed in the following year.
2. **Occupational Advancement**: Whether overeducated workers have a higher rate of upward occupational mobility.
3. **Wage Growth**: Whether the wage growth rate of overeducated workers is faster.

By analyzing data from the Polish Labor Force Survey (2011 to 2018), the paper attempts to verify these hypotheses and explore whether overeducation is indeed a temporary phenomenon and its impact on workers' employment status and income. The study finds that although overeducated workers are more likely to remain employed, the adjustment speed to better-matched jobs is very slow, which contradicts the Sicherman-Galor hypothesis. However, in certain cases (especially among middle-aged workers), the wage growth rate of overeducated workers is indeed faster.