Abstract:Background/Context School tracking practices have been documented repeatedly as having negative effects on students’ identity development and attainment, particularly for those students placed in lower tracks. Despite this documentation, tracking persists as a normative practice in American high schools, perhaps in part because we have few models of how departments and teachers can successfully organize instruction in heterogeneous, high school mathematics classes. This paper offers one such model through a qualitative and quantitative analysis. Focus of Study In an effort to better the field's understanding of equitable and successful teaching, we conducted a longitudinal study of three high schools. At one school, Railside, students demonstrated greater gains in achievement than students at the other two schools and higher overall achievement on a number of measures. Furthermore, achievement gaps among various ethnic groups at Railside that were present on incoming assessments disappeared in nearly all cases by the end of the second year. This paper provides an analysis of Railside's success and identifies factors that contributed to this success. Participants Participants included approximately 700 students as they progressed through three California high schools. Railside was an urban high school with an ethnically, linguistically, and economically diverse student body. Greendale was situated in a coastal community with a more homogeneous, primarily White student body. Hilltop was a rural high school with primarily White and Latino/a students. Research Design This longitudinal, multiple case study employed mixed methods. Three schools were chosen to offer a range of curricular programs and varied student populations. Student achievement and attitudinal data were evaluated using statistical techniques, whereas teacher and student practices were documented using qualitative analytic techniques such as coding. Findings/Results One of the findings of the study was the success of Railside school, where the mathematics department taught heterogeneous classes using a reform-oriented approach. Compared with the other two schools in the study, Railside students learned more, enjoyed mathematics more and progressed to higher mathematics levels. This paper presents large-scale evidence of these important achievements and provides detailed analyses of the ways that the Railside teachers brought them about, with a focus on the teaching and learning interactions within the classrooms.

The Effects of Clustering and Curriculum on the Development of Gifted Learners' Math Achievement

Lessons from the Field: Examining the Challenges and Successes of a Mathematics and Science Program Using Acceleration and Enrichment for Gifted Urban Middle School Students

What Works in Gifted Education

Development of an identification procedure for a large urban school corporation: Identifying culturally diverse and academically gifted elementary students

Effective teaching strategies for teaching mathematics to young gifted English learners

Building Systemic Capacity to Improve Identification and Services in Gifted Education: A Case Study of One District

Connecting Teacher Professional Development and Student Mathematics Achievement

Connecting Teacher Professional Development and Student Mathematics Achievement: A 4-Year Study of an Elementary Mathematics Specialist Program

Cluster (school) RCT of ParentCorps: impact on kindergarten academic achievement

Underachievement Among Spatially Gifted Students

Early Math Coursework and College Readiness: Evidence from Targeted Middle School Math Acceleration

Comparison of the effects of project-based computer programming activities between mathematics-gifted students and average students

Consequences of Implementing Curricular-Aligned Strategies for Identifying Rural Gifted Students

Do Mathematics and Reading Skills Impact Student Science Outcomes?

Preschool Mathematics Intervention Can Significantly Improve Student Learning Trajectories Through Elementary School

Creating Mathematical Futures through an Equitable Teaching Approach: The Case of Railside School

Effects of a reform high school mathematics curriculum on student achievement: whom does it benefit?

Longitudinally adaptive assessment and instruction increase numerical skills of preschool children

Importance of Middle School Mathematics on High School Students' Mathematics Achievement

Effective Programs in Middle and High School Mathematics: A Best-Evidence Synthesis

Inequality at the Starting Line: Underrepresentation in Gifted Identification and Disparities in Early Achievement