Systematic study of flow vector fluctuations in TeV Pb-Pb collisions

S. Acharya,D. Adamová,A. Agarwal,G. Aglieri Rinella,L. Aglietta,M. Agnello,N. Agrawal,Z. Ahammed,S. Ahmad,S. U. Ahn,I. Ahuja,A. Akindinov,V. Akishina,M. Al-Turany,D. Aleksandrov,B. Alessandro,H. M. Alfanda,R. Alfaro Molina,B. Ali,A. Alici,N. Alizadehvandchali,A. Alkin,J. Alme,G. Alocco,T. Alt,A. R. Altamura,I. Altsybeev,J. R. Alvarado,M. N. Anaam,C. Andrei,N. Andreou,A. Andronic,E. Andronov,V. Anguelov,F. Antinori,P. Antonioli,N. Apadula,L. Aphecetche,H. Appelshäuser,C. Arata,S. Arcelli,M. Aresti,R. Arnaldi,J. G. M. C. A. Arneiro,I. C. Arsene,M. Arslandok,A. Augustinus,R. Averbeck,M. D. Azmi,H. Baba,A. Badalà,J. Bae,Y. W. Baek,X. Bai,R. Bailhache,Y. Bailung,R. Bala,A. Balbino,A. Baldisseri,B. Balis,D. Banerjee,Z. Banoo,V. Barbasova,F. Barile,L. Barioglio,M. Barlou,B. Barman,G. G. Barnaföldi,L. S. Barnby,E. Barreau,V. Barret,L. Barreto,C. Bartels,K. Barth,E. Bartsch,N. Bastid,S. Basu,G. Batigne,D. Battistini,B. Batyunya,D. Bauri,J. L. Bazo Alba,I. G. Bearden,C. Beattie,P. Becht,D. Behera,I. Belikov,A. D. C. Bell Hechavarria,F. Bellini,R. Bellwied,S. Belokurova,L. G. E. Beltran,Y. A. V. Beltran,G. Bencedi,A. Bensaoula,S. Beole,Y. Berdnikov,A. Berdnikova,L. Bergmann,M. G. Besoiu,L. Betev,P. P. Bhaduri,A. Bhasin,M. A. Bhat,B. Bhattacharjee,L. Bianchi,N. Bianchi,J. Bielčík,J. Bielčíková,A. P. Bigot,A. Bilandzic,G. Biro,S. Biswas,N. Bize,J. T. Blair,D. Blau,M. B. Blidaru,N. Bluhme,C. Blume,G. Boca,F. Bock,T. Bodova,J. Bok,L. Boldizsár,M. Bombara,P. M. Bond,G. Bonomi,H. Borel,A. Borissov,A. G. Borquez Carcamo,H. Bossi,E. Botta,Y. E. M. Bouziani,L. Bratrud,P. Braun-Munzinger,M. Bregant,M. Broz,G. E. Bruno,M. D. Buckland,D. Budnikov,H. Buesching,S. Bufalino,P. Buhler,N. Burmasov,Z. Buthelezi,A. Bylinkin,S. A. Bysiak,J. C. Cabanillas Noris,M. F. T. Cabrera,M. Cai,H. Caines,A. Caliva,E. Calvo Villar,J. M. M. Camacho,P. Camerini,F. D. M. Canedo,S. L. Cantway,M. Carabas,A. A. Carballo,F. Carnesecchi,R. Caron,L. A. D. Carvalho,J. Castillo Castellanos,M. Castoldi,F. Catalano,S. Cattaruzzi,C. Ceballos Sanchez,R. Cerri,I. Chakaberia,P. Chakraborty,S. Chandra,S. Chapeland,M. Chartier,S. Chattopadhay,S. Chattopadhyay,S. Chattopadhyay,T. Cheng,C. Cheshkov,V. Chibante Barroso,D. D. Chinellato,E. S. Chizzali,J. Cho,S. Cho,P. Chochula,Z. A. Chochulska,D. Choudhury,P. Christakoglou,C. H. Christensen,P. Christiansen,T. Chujo,M. Ciacco,C. Cicalo,M. R. Ciupek,G. Clai,F. Colamaria,J. S. Colburn,D. Colella,M. Colocci,M. Concas,G. Conesa Balbastre,Z. Conesa del Valle,G. Contin,J. G. Contreras,M. L. Coquet,P. Cortese,M. R. Cosentino,F. Costa,S. Costanza,C. Cot,J. Crkovská,P. Crochet,R. Cruz-Torres,P. Cui,A. Dainese,G. Dange,M. C. Danisch,A. Danu,P. Das,P. Das,S. Das,A. R. Dash,S. Dash,A. De Caro,G. de Cataldo,J. de Cuveland,A. De Falco,D. De Gruttola,N. De Marco,C. De Martin,S. De Pasquale,R. Deb,R. Del Grande,L. Dello Stritto,W. Deng,K. C. Devereaux,P. Dhankher,D. Di Bari,A. Di Mauro,B. Diab,R. A. Diaz,T. Dietel,Y. Ding,J. Ditzel,R. Divià,D. U. Dixit,Ø. Djuvsland,U. Dmitrieva,A. Dobrin,B. Dönigus,J. M. Dubinski,A. Dubla,S. Dudi,P. Dupieux,N. Dzalaiova,T. M. Eder,R. J. Ehlers,F. Eisenhut,R. Ejima,D. Elia,B. Erazmus,F. Ercolessi,B. Espagnon,G. Eulisse,D. Evans,S. Evdokimov,L. Fabbietti,M. Faggin,J. Faivre,F. Fan,W. Fan,A. Fantoni,M. Fasel,A. Feliciello,G. Feofilov,A. Fernández Téllez,L. Ferrandi,M. B. Ferrer,A. Ferrero,C. Ferrero,A. Ferretti,V. J. G. Feuillard,V. Filova,D. Finogeev,F. M. Fionda,E. Flatland,F. Flor,A. N. Flores,S. Foertsch,I. Fokin,S. Fokin,U. Follo,E. Fragiacomo,E. Frajna,U. Fuchs,N. Funicello,C. Furget,A. Furs,T. Fusayasu,J. J. Gaardhøje,M. Gagliardi,A. M. Gago,T. Gahlaut,C. D. Galvan,D. R. Gangadharan,P. Ganoti,C. Garabatos,J. M. Garcia,T. García Chávez,E. Garcia-Solis,C. Gargiulo,P. Gasik,H. M. Gaur,A. Gautam,M. B. Gay Ducati,M. Germain,A. Ghimouz,C. Ghosh,M. Giacalone,G. Gioachin,P. Giubellino,P. Giubilato,A. M. C. Glaenzer,P. Glässel,E. Glimos,D. J. Q. Goh,V. Gonzalez,P. Gordeev,M. Gorgon,K. Goswami,S. Gotovac,V. Grabski,L. K. Graczykowski,E. Grecka,A. Grelli,C. Grigoras,V. Grigoriev,S. Grigoryan,F. Grosa,J. F. Grosse-Oetringhaus,R. Grosso,D. Grund,N. A. Grunwald,G. G. Guardiano,R. Guernane,M. Guilbaud,K. Gulbrandsen,T. Gündem,T. Gunji,W. Guo,A. Gupta,R. Gupta,R. Gupta,K. Gwizdziel,L. Gyulai,C. Hadjidakis,F. U. Haider,S. Haidlova,M. Haldar,H. Hamagaki,A. Hamdi,Y. Han,B. G. Hanley,R. Hannigan,J. Hansen,M. R. Haque,J. W. Harris,A. Harton,M. V. Hartung,H. Hassan,D. Hatzifotiadou,P. Hauer,L. B. Havener,E. Hellbär,H. Helstrup,M. Hemmer,T. Herman,S. G. Hernandez,G. Herrera Corral,F. Herrmann,S. Herrmann,K. F. Hetland,B. Heybeck,H. Hillemanns,B. Hippolyte,F. W. Hoffmann,B. Hofman,G. H. Hong,M. Horst,A. Horzyk,Y. Hou,P. Hristov,P. Huhn,L. M. Huhta,T. J. Humanic,A. Hutson,D. Hutter,M. C. Hwang,R. Ilkaev,M. Inaba,G. M. Innocenti,M. Ippolitov,A. Isakov,T. Isidori,M. S. Islam,S. Iurchenko,M. Ivanov,M. Ivanov,V. Ivanov,K. E. Iversen,M. Jablonski,B. Jacak,N. Jacazio,P. M. Jacobs,S. Jadlovska,J. Jadlovsky,S. Jaelani,C. Jahnke,M. J. Jakubowska,M. A. Janik,T. Janson,S. Ji,S. Jia,A. A. P. Jimenez,F. Jonas,D. M. Jones,J. M. Jowett,J. Jung,M. Jung,A. Junique,A. Jusko,J. Kaewjai,P. Kalinak,A. Kalweit,A. Karasu Uysal,D. Karatovic,O. Karavichev,T. Karavicheva,E. Karpechev,M. J. Karwowska,U. Kebschull,R. Keidel,M. Keil,B. Ketzer,S. S. Khade,A. M. Khan,S. Khan,A. Khanzadeev,Y. Kharlov,A. Khatun,A. Khuntia,Z. Khuranova,B. Kileng,B. Kim,C. Kim,D. J. Kim,E. J. Kim,J. Kim,J. Kim,J. Kim,M. Kim,S. Kim,T. Kim,K. Kimura,A. Kirkova,S. Kirsch,I. Kisel,S. Kiselev,A. Kisiel,J. P. Kitowski,J. L. Klay,J. Klein,S. Klein,C. Klein-Bösing,M. Kleiner,T. Klemenz,A. Kluge,C. Kobdaj,R. Kohara,T. Kollegger,A. Kondratyev,N. Kondratyeva,J. Konig,S. A. Konigstorfer,P. J. Konopka,G. Kornakov,M. Korwieser,S. D. Koryciak,C. Koster,A. Kotliarov,N. Kovacic,V. Kovalenko,M. Kowalski,V. Kozhuharov,I. Králik,A. Kravčáková,L. Krcal,M. Krivda,F. Krizek,K. Krizkova Gajdosova,C. Krug,M. Krüger,D. M. Krupova,E. Kryshen,V. Kučera,C. Kuhn,P. G. Kuijer,T. Kumaoka,D. Kumar,L. Kumar,N. Kumar,S. Kumar,S. Kundu,P. Kurashvili,A. Kurepin,A. B. Kurepin,A. Kuryakin,S. Kushpil,V. Kuskov,M. Kutyla,M. J. Kweon,Y. Kwon,S. L. La Pointe,P. La Rocca,A. Lakrathok,M. Lamanna,A. R. Landou,R. Langoy,P. Larionov,E. Laudi,L. Lautner,R. A. N. Laveaga,R. Lavicka,R. Lea,H. Lee,I. Legrand,G. Legras,J. Lehrbach,T. M. Lelek,R. C. Lemmon,I. León Monzón,M. M. Lesch,E. D. Lesser,P. Lévai,M. Li,X. Li,B. E. Liang-gilman,J. Lien,R. Lietava,I. Likmeta,B. Lim,S. H. Lim,V. Lindenstruth,A. Lindner,C. Lippmann,D. H. Liu,J. Liu,G. S. S. Liveraro,I. M. Lofnes,C. Loizides,S. Lokos,J. Lömker,X. Lopez,E. López Torres,P. Lu,F. V. Lugo,J. R. Luhder,M. Lunardon,G. Luparello,Y. G. Ma,M. Mager,A. Maire,E. M. Majerz,M. V. Makariev,M. Malaev,G. Malfattore,N. M. Malik,Q. W. Malik,S. K. Malik,L. Malinina,D. Mallick,N. Mallick,G. Mandaglio,S. K. Mandal,A. Manea,V. Manko,F. Manso,V. Manzari,Y. Mao,R. W. Marcjan,G. V. Margagliotti,A. Margotti,A. Marín,C. Markert,P. Martinengo,M. I. Martínez,G. Martínez García,M. P. P. Martins,S. Masciocchi,M. Masera,A. Masoni,L. Massacrier,O. Massen,A. Mastroserio,O. Matonoha,S. Mattiazzo,A. Matyja,A. L. Mazuecos,F. Mazzaschi,M. Mazzilli,J. E. Mdhluli,Y. Melikyan,A. Menchaca-Rocha,J. E. M. Mendez,E. Meninno,A. S. Menon,M. W. Menzel,M. Meres,Y. Miake,L. Micheletti,D. L. Mihaylov,K. Mikhaylov,N. Minafra,D. Miśkowiec,A. Modak,B. Mohanty,M. Mohisin Khan,M. A. Molander,S. Monira,C. Mordasini,D. A. Moreira De Godoy,I. Morozov,A. Morsch,T. Mrnjavac,V. Muccifora,S. Muhuri,J. D. Mulligan,A. Mulliri,M. G. Munhoz,R. H. Munzer,H. Murakami,S. Murray,L. Musa,J. Musinsky,J. W. Myrcha,B. Naik,A. I. Nambrath,B. K. Nandi,R. Nania,E. Nappi,A. F. Nassirpour,A. Nath,C. Nattrass,M. N. Naydenov,A. Neagu,A. Negru,E. Nekrasova,L. Nellen,R. Nepeivoda,S. Nese,G. Neskovic,N. Nicassio,B. S. Nielsen,E. G. Nielsen,S. Nikolaev,S. Nikulin,V. Nikulin,F. Noferini,S. Noh,P. Nomokonov,J. Norman,N. Novitzky,P. Nowakowski,A. Nyanin,J. Nystrand,S. Oh,A. Ohlson,V. A. Okorokov,J. Oleniacz,A. Onnerstad,C. Oppedisano,A. Ortiz Velasquez,J. Otwinowski,M. Oya,K. Oyama,Y. Pachmayer,S. Padhan,D. Pagano,G. Paić,S. Paisano-Guzmán,A. Palasciano,S. Panebianco,H. Park,H. Park,J. E. Parkkila,Y. Patley,B. Paul,M. M. D. M. Paulino,H. Pei,T. Peitzmann,X. Peng,M. Pennisi,S. Perciballi,D. Peresunko,G. M. Perez,Y. Pestov,V. Petrov,M. Petrovici,S. Piano,M. Pikna,P. Pillot,O. Pinazza,L. Pinsky,C. Pinto,S. Pisano,M. Płoskoń,M. Planinic,F. Pliquett,M. G. Poghosyan,B. Polichtchouk,S. Politano,N. Poljak,A. Pop,S. Porteboeuf-Houssais,V. Pozdniakov,I. Y. Pozos,K. K. Pradhan,S. K. Prasad,S. Prasad,R. Preghenella,F. Prino,C. A. Pruneau,I. Pshenichnov,M. Puccio,S. Pucillo,S. Qiu,L. Quaglia,S. Ragoni,A. Rai,A. Rakotozafindrabe,L. Ramello,F. Rami,M. Rasa,S. S. Räsänen,R. Rath,M. P. Rauch,I. Ravasenga,K. F. Read,C. Reckziegel,A. R. Redelbach,K. Redlich,C. A. Reetz,H. D. Regules-Medel,A. Rehman,F. Reidt,H. A. Reme-Ness,Z. Rescakova,K. Reygers,A. Riabov,V. Riabov,R. Ricci,M. Richter,A. A. Riedel,W. Riegler,A. G. Riffero,C. Ripoli,C. Ristea,M. V. Rodriguez,M. Rodríguez Cahuantzi,S. A. Rodríguez Ramírez,K. Røed,R. Rogalev,E. Rogochaya,T. S. Rogoschinski,D. Rohr,D. Röhrich,S. Rojas Torres,P. S. Rokita,G. Romanenko,F. Ronchetti,E. D. Rosas,K. Roslon,A. Rossi,A. Roy,S. Roy,N. Rubini,D. Ruggiano,R. Rui,P. G. Russek,R. Russo,A. Rustamov,E. Ryabinkin,Y. Ryabov,A. Rybicki,J. Ryu,W. Rzesa,S. Sadhu,S. Sadovsky,J. Saetre,K. Šafařík,S. K. Saha,S. Saha,B. Sahoo,R. Sahoo,S. Sahoo,D. Sahu,P. K. Sahu,J. Saini,K. Sajdakova,S. Sakai,M. P. Salvan,S. Sambyal,D. Samitz,I. Sanna,T. B. Saramela,D. Sarkar,P. Sarma,V. Sarritzu,V. M. Sarti,M. H. P. Sas,S. Sawan,E. Scapparone,J. Schambach,H. S. Scheid,C. Schiaua,R. Schicker,F. Schlepper,A. Schmah,C. Schmidt,H. R. Schmidt,M. O. Schmidt,M. Schmidt,N. V. Schmidt,A. R. Schmier,R. Schotter,A. Schröter,J. Schukraft,K. Schweda,G. Scioli,E. Scomparin,J. E. Seger,Y. Sekiguchi,D. Sekihata,M. Selina,I. Selyuzhenkov,S. Senyukov,J. J. Seo,D. Serebryakov,L. Serkin,L. Šerkšnytė,A. Sevcenco,T. J. Shaba,A. Shabetai,R. Shahoyan,A. Shangaraev,B. Sharma,D. Sharma,H. Sharma,M. Sharma,S. Sharma,S. Sharma,U. Sharma,A. Shatat,O. Sheibani,K. Shigaki,M. Shimomura,J. Shin,S. Shirinkin,Q. Shou,Y. Sibiriak,S. Siddhanta,T. Siemiarczuk,T. F. Silva,D. Silvermyr,T. Simantathammakul,R. Simeonov,B. Singh,B. Singh,K. Singh,R. Singh,R. Singh,R. Singh,S. Singh,V. K. Singh,V. Singhal,T. Sinha,B. Sitar,M. Sitta,T. B. Skaali,G. Skorodumovs,N. Smirnov,R. J. M. Snellings,E. H. Solheim,J. Song,C. Sonnabend,J. M. Sonneveld,F. Soramel,A. B. Soto-hernandez,R. Spijkers,I. Sputowska,J. Staa,J. Stachel,I. Stan,P. J. Steffanic,S. F. Stiefelmaier,D. Stocco,I. Storehaug,N. J. Strangmann,P. Stratmann,S. Strazzi,A. Sturniolo,C. P. Stylianidis,A. A. P. Suaide,C. Suire,M. Sukhanov,M. Suljic,R. Sultanov,V. Sumberia,S. Sumowidagdo,I. Szarka,M. Szymkowski,S. F. Taghavi,G. Taillepied,J. Takahashi,G. J. Tambave,S. Tang,Z. Tang,J. D. Tapia Takaki,N. Tapus,L. A. Tarasovicova,M. G. Tarzila,G. F. Tassielli,A. Tauro,A. Tavira García,G. Tejeda Muñoz,A. Telesca,L. Terlizzi,C. Terrevoli,S. Thakur,D. Thomas,A. Tikhonov,N. Tiltmann,A. R. Timmins,M. Tkacik,T. Tkacik,A. Toia,R. Tokumoto,S. Tomassini,K. Tomohiro,N. Topilskaya,M. Toppi,T. Tork,V. V. Torres,A. G. Torres Ramos,A. Trifiró,A. S. Triolo,S. Tripathy,T. Tripathy,V. Trubnikov,W. H. Trzaska,T. P. Trzcinski,A. Tumkin,R. Turrisi,T. S. Tveter,K. Ullaland,B. Ulukutlu,A. Uras,M. Urioni,G. L. Usai,M. Vala,N. Valle,L. V. R. van Doremalen,M. van Leeuwen,C. A. van Veen,R. J. G. van Weelden,P. Vande Vyvre,D. Varga,Z. Varga,P. Vargas Torres,M. Vasileiou,A. Vasiliev,O. Vázquez Doce,O. Vazquez Rueda,V. Vechernin,E. Vercellin,S. Vergara Limón,R. Verma,L. Vermunt,R. Vértesi,M. Verweij,L. Vickovic,Z. Vilakazi,O. Villalobos Baillie,A. Villani,A. Vinogradov,T. Virgili,M. M. O. Virta,V. Vislavicius,A. Vodopyanov,B. Volkel,M. A. Völkl,S. A. Voloshin,G. Volpe,B. von Haller,I. Vorobyev,N. Vozniuk,J. Vrláková,J. Wan,C. Wang,D. Wang,Y. Wang,Y. Wang,A. Wegrzynek,F. T. Weiglhofer,S. C. Wenzel,J. P. Wessels,J. Wiechula,J. Wikne,G. Wilk,J. Wilkinson,G. A. Willems,B. Windelband,M. Winn,J. R. Wright,W. Wu,Y. Wu,Z. Xiong,R. Xu,A. Yadav,A. K. Yadav,Y. Yamaguchi,S. Yang,S. Yano,E. R. Yeats,Z. Yin,I.-K. Yoo,J. H. Yoon,H. Yu,S. Yuan,A. Yuncu,V. Zaccolo,C. Zampolli,M. Zang,F. Zanone,N. Zardoshti,A. Zarochentsev,P. Závada,N. Zaviyalov,M. Zhalov,B. Zhang,C. Zhang,L. Zhang,M. Zhang,S. Zhang,X. Zhang,Y. Zhang,Z. Zhang,M. Zhao,V. Zherebchevskii,Y. Zhi,C. Zhong,D. Zhou,Y. Zhou,J. Zhu,S. Zhu,Y. Zhu,S. C. Zugravel,N. Zurlo,ALICE Collaboration
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/physrevc.109.065202
IF: 3.199
2024-06-14
Physical Review C
Abstract:Measurements of the pT -dependent flow vector fluctuations in Pb–Pb collisions at sNN=5.02TeV using azimuthal correlations with the ALICE experiment at the Large Hadron Collider are presented. A four-particle correlation approach [ALICE Collaboration, Phys. Rev. C 107 , L051901 (2023)] is used to quantify the effects of flow angle and magnitude fluctuations separately. This paper extends previous studies to additional centrality intervals and provides measurements of the pT -dependent flow vector fluctuations at sNN=5.02TeV with two-particle correlations. Significant pT -dependent fluctuations of the V⃗2 flow vector in Pb–Pb collisions are found across different centrality ranges, with the largest fluctuations of up to ∼15% being present in the 5% most central collisions. In parallel, no evidence of significant pT -dependent fluctuations of V⃗3 or V⃗4 is found. Additionally, evidence of flow angle and magnitude fluctuations is observed with more than 5σ significance in central collisions. These observations in Pb–Pb collisions indicate where the classical picture of hydrodynamic modeling with a common symmetry plane breaks down. This has implications for hard probes at high pT , which might be biased by pT -dependent flow angle fluctuations of at least 23% in central collisions. Given the presented results, existing theoretical models should be reexamined to improve our understanding of initial conditions, quark–gluon plasma properties, and the dynamic evolution of the created system. https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevC.109.065202 Published by the American Physical Society under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International license. Further distribution of this work must maintain attribution to the author(s) and the published article's title, journal citation, and DOI. Open access publication funded by CERN. ©2024 CERN, for the ALICE Collaboration
physics, nuclear
What problem does this paper attempt to address?