A statistical approach for the use of environmental quality standards (EQS) in marine sediments in the environmental quality assessment of harbor areas

Ausili A.,Bergamin L.,Ciotoli G.,Finoia M.G.,Romano E.
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11368-023-03549-0
IF: 3.5361
2023-05-24
Journal of Soils and Sediments
Abstract:PurposeThe environmental quality standards (EQSs) were defined by the Water Framework Directive (2000/60/EC) and daughter directives for hindering the chemical pollution of surface water bodies. For substances with poor solubility in water and/or the tendency to bioaccumulate along the food chain, member states could choose to define the EQSs on sediments and marine organisms if they guarantee the same level of protection of the EQSs derived for water. Also, Italy defined them on sediments without considering harbors because of their role as pressure sources. Considering the available environmental information, this study focused on verifying the applicability and possible limits of the EQSs in sediments from different Italian harbors.Materials and methodsA dataset with concentrations of metals and trace elements (MTEs) and organic compounds (OCs) from the sediments of 34 Italian harbors was assessed. Grain size parameters were also included for complete information on sediment characteristics. Data were processed through univariate statistics to identify the position of the EQSs within the whole distribution of concentration values. Moreover, a logistic model was applied to verify the probability of exceeding the EQSs for at least one parameter (susceptibility) in the harbor areas.Results and discussionThe EQSs of all MTEs were found close to the overall medians, demonstrating that they are suitable values for highlighting widespread metal contamination, also recognizable in the output of the logistic model, where wide areas with a homogeneous susceptibility were highlighted. The EQSs of most OCs resulted considerably higher than the overall medians, but a minor part of the data exceeded them by far, demonstrating that the contamination was characterized by patchy distribution, as also shown by the susceptibility maps.ConclusionsApplying a statistical approach, this study tried to compare the distribution of concentration data with the EQSs of sediments based on a specific dataset containing many records from many Italian harbors. The logistic model applied in this study, based on the excess of the EQSs for at least one parameter, represented a robust tool to define areas at high susceptibility in the harbors and confirmed their adaptability also in these highly impacted areas.
soil science,environmental sciences
What problem does this paper attempt to address?