Abstract:Background: Using the Activity Theory of education (Galperin, 1992; Talyzina, 2018), this article examines the students' actions that constitute the early stages of forming the concept of ratios. The psychological analysis of mastery of this concept shows that it essentially depends on understanding the coordination of the changes of two independent values (area, velocity, density, etc.). Objective: The present research considers differences in students' operations with numbers on various tasks, based on their comprehension of ratio relations (direct and inverse proportions); these differences are revealed through posing certain modified tasks, but may stay unnoticed in regular tasks. The goal of the study was to identify the criteria for adequate assessment of the sustainability of the students' orientation in modified tasks. Design: A test of 15 tasks was designed based on Galperin's classification of task variations: domain specific, logical, and psychological. The formulation of the tasks disguised the operations needed to achieve the right answer, and sometimes even prompted the wrong solution. There were 12 tasks on direct proportions - four sample and eight modified; and three inverse proportion tasks: one sample and two modified. One hundred sixty (160) students (5-6th grade, 11-13 years old) took the test in writing. Results: The comparison of students' performance on the sample and modified tasks showed significant differences. Modifications impaired the students' performance on both types of proportion problems (direct and inverse). Logical and psychological modifications had the most impact on the quality of the students' orientation and thus proved to be most indicative in terms of students' orientation quality assessment. Conclusion: The data suggest the following: 1) that the concepts of proportionality which the students acquired from a regular school curriculum lack "generalization," and 2) that students' ability to apply the ratio concept is very sensitive to the way the word problem is presented. These findings are essential for evaluating students' multiplicative thinking: their actual level of comprehension cannot be revealed through their performance on regular tasks.

Analysis of Justification for the Inclusion Relation about Division and Proportional Distribution in Elementary School Students

Three Foci of Mathematic Teachers' Considerations in Evaluation of School Students' Achievements

A Didactical Analysis on the Teaching of Principle of Division Algorithm in the Korean Elementary Mathematics Textbooks

Teachers Promoting Mathematical Reasoning in Tasks

Exploring Aspects of Mathematical Reasoning in Elementary School Mathematics Textbook: Focusing on Geometry-related Units for Grades 3-4

A Comparative Study of Secondary School Mathematics Teaching Materials from the Perspective of Reasoning--Taking "Pythagorean Theorem" as an Example

A framework for reasoning in school mathematics: analyzing the development of mathematical claims

Middle School Mathematics Teachers' Reasoning about Students' Nonstandard Strategies: Division of Fractions

On recognizing proportionality: Does the ability to solve missing value proportional problems presuppose the conception of proportional reasoning?

DEDUCTIVE OR INDUCTIVE? PROSPECTIVE TEACHERS’ PREFERENCE OF PROOF METHOD ON AN INTERMEDIATE PROOF TASK

An analysis of teacher knowledge for teaching functional thinking to elementary school students

Ratio and Proportion: Connecting Content and Children's Thinking

Transforming Perceptions of Proof: A Four-Part Instructional Sequence

Student Obstacles in Ratio and Proportion Learning

Effects of The Geometer’s Sketchpad on Algebraic Reasoning Among Junior Private High School Students

An Experiment in Teaching Ratio and Proportion

Relation Between Mathematical Proof Problem Solving, Math Anxiety, Self-Efficacy, Learning Engagement, and Backward Reasoning

Student facility with ratio and proportion: Mapping the reasoning space in introductory physics

A study on teaching of reasoning about variation: Focusing on statistics unit in 3rd and 4th grade of elementary school

The Deficits of Students' Orientation in Solving Proportion Problems, as Revealed through Task Modifications

Analysis of difficulties for pre-service mathematics teacher in problem solving of division and divisibility based on theory of action, process, object, and schemes