Abstract:Reform documents advocate for innovative pedagogical strategies to enhance student learning. A key innovation is the integration of science and engineering practices through Engineering Design (ED)-based physics laboratory tasks, where students tackle engineering design problems by applying physics principles. While this approach has its benefits, research shows that students do not always effectively apply scientific concepts, but instead rely on trial-and-error approaches, and end up gadgeteering their way to a solution. This leads to what is commonly referred to as the "design-science gap" -- that students do not always consciously apply science concepts while solving a design problem. However, as obvious as the notion of a `gap' may appear, there seems to exist no consensus on the definitions of `design' and `science', further complicating the understanding of this `gap'. This qualitative study addresses the notion of the design-science gap by examining student-groups' discussions and written lab reports from a multi-week ED-based undergraduate introductory physics laboratory task. Building on our earlier studies, we developed and employed a nuanced, multi-layered coding scheme inspired by the Gioia Framework to characterize `design thinking' and `science thinking'. We discuss how student-groups engage in various aspects of design and how they apply concepts physics principles to solve the problem. In the process, we demonstrate the interconnectedness of students' design thinking and science thinking. We advocate for the usage of the term ``design--science connection'' as opposed to ``design--science gap'' to deepen both design and scientific thinking. Our findings offer valuable insights for educators in design-based science education.

Communication as Design: How a Multimodal Assignment Establishes Communication’s Role in Engineering Design and Provides Stability to a Large Course System

Professional communication and a 'whole new mind': Engaging with ethics, intellectual property, design, and globalization

Innovation Across the Curriculum: Three Case Studies in Teaching Science and Engineering Communication

Digital natives and digital media in the college classroom: assignment design and impacts on student learning

Teaching Interdisciplinary Design Between Architecture and Engineering: Finding Common Ground While Retaining Disciplinary Expertise

Creating interdisciplinary collaborative teaching/learning praxis with design thinking, communication, and composition

Teaching Writing and Communication in a Mathematical Modeling Course

Designing an interdisciplinary course: case study of an interdisciplinary project combining marketing research, engineering, and media arts

Teaching Technical Communication to Engineering Students: Design, Implementation, and Assessment for Project-based Instruction

Towards a student-centered lab design for learning principles of communications

A sociocultural approach to communication instruction: How insights from communication teaching practices can inform faculty development programs

Teaching Inclusive Engineering Design at a Small Liberal Arts College

Multidisciplinary Student Performance-Based Teaching Design for Engineering Design Via a Commercial Case

Formative feedback and scaffolding for developing complex problem solving and modelling outcomes

Improved content mastery and written communication through a lab-report assignment with peer review: an example from a quantum engineering course

A discourse–design approach to multimodality: the visual communication of neoliberal management discourse

Organizing the Organizational Communication Course: Content and Pedagogical Recommendations

A Problem-Based Learning Approach to Teaching Design in CS1

Improve Engineering Student Engagement through In-Class and Out-Class Interactions

Investigating the Design--Science Connection in a multi-week Engineering Design (ED)-based introductory physics laboratory task

Lessons in Teaching an Interdisciplinary Mechatronics Class