Abstract:To date, China has the world's largest wind power generation capacity, followed by the United States. Yet, China's utilization of this installed capacity trails that of the United States by a huge gap. This paper seeks to explain this gap by focusing on the role of institutions. First, it analyzes the institutions that either facilitate or impede wind integration in the two countries. Next, it synthesizes these institutions into coherent institutional logics for China and the United States. Then, it corroborates the institutional analysis with empirical evidence from China and the United States. Finally, it compares the two countries and summarizes what China can learn from the United States to reduce wind curtailment. Overall, this paper finds that China's dominant institutional logic of wind integration is state centrism and it is complemented by partial decentralization and liberalization – a system that is more conducive to capacity addition than capacity utilization. By contrast, the United States' dominant institutional logic of wind integration is market competition but a competing logic also exists which is regulatory interventionism – a system that aligns capacity addition and utilization better but engenders greater policy uncertainty. Because the two countries have distinct institutional logics that generate different root causes for wind curtailment, this paper argues that simply transplanting solutions from the United States to China will not work. What China can learn from the United States is to make incremental improvements to address the frictions between its dominant and complementary institutional logics.

Network governance and effectiveness on renewable energy integration: A comparative case study on power transmission networks in the United States

Integrated Transmission Network Planning by Considering Wind Power's Uncertainty and Disasters

Transmission Network Expansion Planning with Stochastic Multivariate Load and Wind Modeling

Optimization Method for Transmission Network Structure Considering Adaptability of Large-Scale Wind Power Integration

Network Structure and Governance Performance: What Makes a Difference?

Optimal Allocation of Power Capacity Configuration in Incremental Distribution Network under Different Operation Modes

Evolution Logic and Comparative Advantage of China’s Power System Reform—A Comparative Study on Transmission Management Between China and the United States

Coordination Planning of Wind Farm, Energy Storage and Transmission Network with High-Penetration Renewable Energy

Offshore Transmission Network Planning for Wind Integration Considering AC and DC Transmission Options

Wind Power Transmission System Integration -- a Case Study of China Wind Power Base

Multi-Objective Transmission Expansion: An Offshore Wind Power Integration Case Study

Properties and Structural Analyses of USA's Regional Electricity Market: A Visibility Graph Network Approach

A Model for Power System Transmission Network Expansion Planning under Low-Carbon Economy

The Politics of Network Governance in Europe: The Case of Energy Regulation

Renewable Power Trades and Network Congestion Externalities

The Institutional Logic of Wind Energy Integration: What Can China Learn from the United States to Reduce Wind Curtailment?

Properties and structural analyses of USA’s regional electricity market: A visibility graph network approach

Assessing the integration effect of inter-regional transmission on variable power generation under renewable energy consumption policy in China

Energy Storage-Transmission Line Planning Based on Complete Information Static Game Model

Emission-Concerned Wind-EV Coordination on the Transmission Grid Side with Network Constraints: Concept and Case Study

HVDC/ HVAC transmission network expansion planning in electricity markets in the presence of wind resources