A Study of Performance Measurement System Implementation in a High Volume Production Line
Eric O. Olsen,Honggeng Zhou,Yoke-Eng Ng,Chow Chewn Chong,Pean Padunchwit
2002-01-01
Abstract:Most managers have heard the platitude "what gets measured gets done", but the fact is that there is little empirical research on what constitutes an effective performance measurement (PM) system. Internal performance measures provide critical infrastructure that allows an operation to 1) document historical performance, 2) indicate current position with respect to operational strategy, 3) predict future performance, and 4) motivate and control behavior. PM system effectiveness can be described as a system's ability to address all of these functions. In order to develop grounded theory in PM system design and analysis, a single longitudinal case study was undertaken on a subassembly process in Hewlett Packard's high volume Inkjet pen cartridge production line in Singapore. A new PM system was introduced to "motivate operators to higher performance, provide for fairness and consistency in salary related performance evaluation, and encourage ownership in the operation". Measures emphasized workcentre yield, output, housekeeping, teamwork, suggestion system participation, quality workmanship, safety, and operator dependability (attendance) at the individual, team, and production line levels. Each operator was provided a monthly evaluation of his or her individual performance based on a point allocation system. Twenty-seven months of pre and post PM system implementation yield and operator productivity data were compared. Overall, production yield showed a significant increase in both level and rate of improvement. The level of operator productivity also improved significantly over the period studied. Individual performance measure effectiveness with respect to causality, improvement, and control were analyzed. Conclusions are drawn on PM system effectiveness from this analysis and feedback from line management. Recommendations are made for a subsequent round of PM system improvements and future research.