Abstract:This study reveals the impact of the "identifiable victim effect" on prosocial decision‐making and its neural mechanism. Our findings reveal the identifiability of the victim may modulate the mentalizing process, as reflected in the activation of bilateral temporoparietal junction (TPJ), which further modulates the valuation process in decision‐making through the functional connection between the right TPJ and medial prefrontal cortex. The phenomenon known as the "identifiable victim effect" describes how individuals tend to offer more assistance to victims they can identify with than to those who are vague or abstract. The neural underpinnings of this effect, however, remain elusive. Our study utilized functional magnetic resonance imaging to delve into how the "identifiable victim effect" influences prosocial decision‐making, considering different types of helping costs, across two distinct tasks. Participants were instructed to decide whether to help a victim with personal information shown (i.e., the identifiable victim) and an unidentifiable one by costing their money (task 1) or physical effort (task 2). Behaviorally, we observed a pronounced preference in both tasks for aiding identifiable victims over anonymous ones, highlighting a robust "identifiable victim effect." On a neural level, this effect was associated with heightened activity in brain areas like the bilateral temporoparietal junction (TPJ) when participants confronted anonymous victims, potentially indicating a more intensive mentalizing process for less concrete victims. Additionally, we noted that the TPJ's influence on value judgment processes is mediated through its functional connectivity with the medial prefrontal cortex. These insights contribute significantly to our understanding of the psychological and neural dynamics underlying the identifiable victim effect.

How far is the suffering? The role of psychological distance and victims’ identifiability in donation decisions

Helping Yourself Before Helping Others: How Sense of Control Promotes Charitable Behaviors

Income and Geographically Constrained Generosity

Victim identifiability, number of victims, and unit asking in charitable giving

Happy to help—if it’s not too sad: The effect of mood on helping identifiable and unidentifiable victims

Underlying Mechanism to the Identifiable Victim Effect in Collective Donation Action Intentions: Does Emotional Reactions and Perceived Responsibility Matter?

Cultural Differences in Donation Decision-Making

Who helps whom in times of crisis? An investigation of actual donations to two groups of earthquake victims

The elusive power of the individual victim: Failure to find a difference in the effectiveness of charitable appeals focused on one compared to many victims

Helping secondary victims: The influence of vividness and ‘transfer’ of sympathy

Revisiting and Rethinking the Identifiable Victim Effect: Replication and Extension of Small, Loewenstein, and Slovic (2007)

The identifiable victim effect in charitable giving: evidence from a natural field experiment

The neural mechanisms of identifiable victim effect in prosocial decision‐making

COVID-19 Charity Advertising: Identifiable Victim Message Framing, Self-Construal, and Donation Intent

Mental Imagery, Impact, and Affect: A Mediation Model for Charitable Giving

Helping the child or the adult? Systematically testing the identifiable victim effect for child and adult victims

Altruistic behavior in cohesive social groups: The role of target identifiability

Victims of misfortune may not “deserve” help: A possible factor in victim-devaluation

Selective attention to pain and empathy: Studying frequent blood donors

Numeracy as a precursor to pro-social behavior: The impact of numeracy and presentation format on the cognitive mechanisms underlying donation decisions

Deciding Who Is Worthy of Help: Effect of the Probability of Reciprocity on Individuals' Willingness to Help Others