Abstract:In recent years, one of the most important and innovative policy initiatives introduced by the Chinese government in the field of environmental protection and ecological civilization construction is the Central Environmental Protection Inspection (CEPI). CEPI is seen as a vital tool to encourage local implementation of environmental protection responsibility. Over the course of its operation (eight years), CEPI has transformed from the "campaign" phase to the "convention" phase. It is noted that while provincial governments face a common high-pressure environment created by CEPI, governance scenarios, behaviors, and performance vary across the country significantly. To better understand local governments' environmental governance behaviors under the transformation of CEPI, an integrated analysis framework consisting of two key elements, "central dominance" and "local proactiveness", is constructed based on the central-local interactions under the principal-agent model. Based on this framework, we conducted a multi-case comparative analysis of four classic cases, with the following findings. (1) Along with the operation of CEPI and its transformation, the interaction between the central and local governments leads to four governance scenarios: "control-active cooperation", "control-passive cooperation", "guidance-active promotion", and "guidance-passive promotion". (2) Influenced by various factors such as pressure by the central government, local governments' capabilities and governance motivations, local governments form governance behaviors with varying degrees of proactiveness and autonomy. (3) After examining the governance performance of varying behaviors, it is found that local government's "active promotion" behavior can achieve higher governance effectiveness in the "convention" phase. Therefore, it is of policy implication that local governments should be guided to transit from "passive cooperation" to "active promotion". This paper has important guiding significance for understanding local environmental governance behaviors under strong top-down institutional pressure.

Facilitating inter-municipal collaboration through mandated collaborative platform: evidence from regional environmental protection in China

Hierarchical Interventions and Environmental Collaboration among Municipal Governments: a Bottom-Up Analysis

The Evolution of Collaborative Networks: A Social Network Analysis of Chinese Environmental Protection Policy

Evaluating Environmental Outcome and Process-Adaptivity of Regional Collaboration: an Empirical Study from China

Environmental Inter-Local Collaboration under Meta-Governance: the Trade-off Between Collective and Selective Benefits

What Drives the Performance of Collaboration Networks: A Qualitative Comparative Analysis of Local Water Governance in China

Assessing and Explaining Interagency Collaboration Performance: a Comparative Case Study of Local Governments in China

Within the Shadow of Hierarchy: the Role of Hierarchical Interventions in Environmental Collaborative Governance

Interlocal Collaborative Processes and Network Position: the Combined Effects on Environmental Performance

The Collaboration of Local Government on Ecological Governance:from the Prospect of the Metropolitan Area of Beijing-Tianjin-Hebei

What is the Role of Hierarchical Interventions? Insights from the Evolution of Water Collaborative Governance in China

Toward a Leading-Agency Coordinated Collaboration Model? Lessons Learned from Interagency Collaboration in Chinese Environmental Protection

Collaborative governance in action: driving ecological sustainability in the Yangtze River basin

Networked Environmental Governance: Formal and Informal Collaborative Networks in Local China

Impact of Structural Dependence on the Formation of Multi-Subject Collaborative Network for Comprehensive Land Consolidation

Leadership in Regional Collaborative Governance: Evidence from the Integration of China’s Yangtze River Delta

How does central-local interaction affect local environmental governance? Insights from the transformation of central environmental protection inspection in China

Regional Governance and Institutional Collective Action for Environmental Sustainability

Impact of Chinese market segmentation on regional collaborative governance of environmental pollution: A new approach to complex system theory

Research on collaborative management and optimization of ecological risks in urban agglomeration

A multilevel social-ecological network approach for reconciling coastal saltmarsh conservation and development