Photographs that repulse or entice: Sense-making and emotional experiencing of artistic photographs.
Nathalie Vissers,Johan Wagemans
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1037/aca0000478
2024-03-28
Abstract:Aesthetic experiences with photographs are common in our digital society, yet there are many gaps in our scientific knowledge about how we look at, and aesthetically appreciate, photographs. Specifically, an in-depth view of these aesthetic experiences that takes into account the nuances of the photograph, as well as the emotional and meaning-making processes in the viewer, is lacking. In this project, we focus on a varied set of 58 contemporary artistic photographs (selected by expert judges) and, in two complementary studies, examine how 259 nonexperts aesthetically experience these photographs, whether contextual changes can impact their aesthetic preferences, and whether participants’ preferences relate to their emotional responses and how they were making meaning of the photographs. In general, participants’ aesthetic experiences varied greatly between photographs but they were robust against contextual changes (of other photographs or theme information). Emotional experience played a key role in participants’ preferences, with low preferences for photographs associated with negative emotions (e.g., blood, sickness, and pollution), and high preferences for photographs associated with positive emotions (e.g., nature and a street scene reminiscent of vacation). Making meaning of (what was in) the photograph was also important, and participants’ answers suggest that they did not always fully understand the photographs or integrate the photographs’ nuances into a coherent whole. Results have implications for empirical aesthetics, the (art) photography practice, and how we are responding to photographs in general.
psychology, experimental