Abstract:The societal security theory posits that extreme anti-migrant hostility – such as demands to deport all migrants unconditionally – emerges when host communities see migration as a threat to the survival of their group identity. An alternative interpretation – the immigration security dilemma – attributes extreme hostility to the human tendency to prepare for the worst under uncertainty when central authority weakens. Does extreme intergroup hostility relate more to threats framed in terms of group survival or to those framed in terms of uncertainty about government capacity and migration effects? I investigate this question empirically with the Russian national survey data (2005, N = 680) asking who in Russia supports the deportation of all internal and external migrants, legal and illegal, and their children to their places of origin – an extreme and widespread view that would require forced population movements not seen in the region since Stalin’s Great Terror. In multivariate tests, agreement with the societal security (survival) rhetoric explained about five percent of variation in support for unconditional, wholesale deportation of migrants; agreement with the security dilemma (uncertainty) rhetoric – about 20%. A comparison of attitudes in the same survey to Armenian, Uzbek, Chechen, and Chinese migrants and the association of each ethnic group with different types of security threat further support this finding. Hostility toward ethnic groups viewed as a weak security threat was more diagnostic of public support for wholesale deportation of migrants than hostility toward groups viewed as a strong security threat.

Is Anti-Immigrant Sentiment Owned by the Political Right?

Eastern Europe is no exception: acceptance of inequality and left–right politics

A comparison of attitudes towards immigrants from the perspective of the political party vote

Strangers in Hostile Lands: Exposure to Refugees and Right-Wing Support in Germany’s Eastern Regions

Predicting the rise of right-wing populism in response to unbalanced immigration

Xenophobia and Left Voting

Social Trust and Anti-immigrant Attitudes in Europe: A Longitudinal Multi-Level Analysis

Psychological needs and values underlying left-right political orientation: Cross-national evidence from Eastern and Western Europe

Attitudes toward immigration in Europe: Cross-regional differences

Does Immigration Undermine Public Support for Social Policy?

Factors Affecting Attitudes Toward Migrants: an International Comparative Study

Changing attitudes toward immigration in Europe, 2002-2007: a dynamic group conflict theory approach

Does Origin Matter? Ethnic Group Position and Attitudes Toward Immigrants: The Case of Russia

Blame it on my youth: the origins of attitudes towards immigration

Is Intending to Have Children Rightist? A Research Note on Political Ideology and Fertility Intentions

The polarizing impact of numeracy, economic literacy, and science literacy on attitudes toward immigration

Societal security, the security dilemma, and extreme anti-migrant hostility in Russia

Between east and west, between past and future: The effects of exclusive historical victimhood on geopolitical attitudes in Hungary and Serbia

Conservative bias, selective political exposure and truly false consensus beliefs in political communication about the ‘refugee crisis’ in Germany

Who thinks the media is hostile?! An examination of individual differences predicting the hostile media effect concerning news media coverage of individuals with a migratory background in Germany

Social Exclusion and Anti-Immigration Attitudes in Europe: The mediating role of Interpersonal Trust