The Concept of Ocean Sustainability in Formal Education—Comparative Ocean Literacy Coverage Analysis of the Educational Standards of India and the USA

Cheng-Chieh Chang,Thakkar Chandni Hirenkumar,Chin-kuo Wu
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/SU13084314
IF: 3.9
2021-04-13
Sustainability
Abstract:The concept of marine environmental sustainability is essential, and ocean literacy is currently at the core of its development. Comparing ocean literacy principles in curriculum standards is an important thing to do. Ocean literacy (OL) is a key and emerging topic, and its study has adopted a qualitative approach and follows the content analysis approach. It was observed that, on average, OL concepts covered in the educational standards of the USA (Next Generation Science Standards, NGSS) are higher than those of India (Indian National Standards, INSs). The study revealed that the 6th principle is highly accentuated in both countries’ educational standards out of the seven essential principles. Moreover, the results indicate variation in OL alignment across India’s grade bands and the USA’s educational standards. Based on the results mentioned above, the proposed study intends to provide references to marine education researchers, curriculum developers, and educational policymakers in India to suitably adjust OL coverage concepts in schools to cultivate ocean-literate citizens.
Political Science,Environmental Science,Education
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### What problem does this paper attempt to solve? This paper aims to compare the coverage of the concept of Ocean Literacy (OL) in formal education between India and the United States and to propose corresponding reference suggestions. #### Specific objectives include: 1. **Comparison Framework**: To present a comparative framework of the coverage of ocean literacy concepts in the educational standards of the United States and India. 2. **Commonalities and Differences**: To verify the similarities and differences in ocean literacy between the Next Generation Science Standards (NGSS) of the United States and the Indian National Standards (INSs) as well as the Indian Central Government Textbooks (ICGTs). #### Main research content: 1. **Importance of Ocean Literacy**: Oceans cover 70% of the Earth's surface and have a significant impact on climate, weather changes, and oxygen levels. Ocean literacy refers to understanding the ocean and its importance and taking responsible actions. 2. **Comparison of Educational Standards**: Through comparative analysis, it was found that the educational standards of the United States (NGSS) have a higher coverage of ocean literacy than the Indian National Standards (INSs). The study also found that the sixth principle (the interconnection between humans and the ocean) is highly emphasized in the educational standards of both countries. 3. **Specific Suggestions**: Based on the above results, the study proposes some suggestions for Indian ocean education researchers, curriculum developers, and education policymakers to appropriately adjust the coverage of ocean literacy concepts in schools to cultivate ocean-literate citizens. #### Methodology: 1. **Qualitative and Quantitative Methods**: The study adopted qualitative methods to explain the research of people, cases, phenomena, and social processes, combined with quantitative methods for data analysis. 2. **Data Sources**: By conducting content analysis of the educational standards of the United States and India, relevant data were extracted and compared. Through this research, the paper aims to provide a reference basis for the reform of ocean education in India, thereby enhancing the level of ocean literacy among students.