Abstract:Despite advancements in pedicle screw design and surgical techniques, the standard steps for inserting pedicle screws still need to follow a set of fixed procedures. The first step, known as establishing a pilot hole, also referred to as a pre-drilled hole, is crucial for ensuring screw insertion accuracy. In different surgical approaches, such as minimally invasive or traditional surgery, the method of creating pilot holes varies, resulting in different pilot hole profiles, including variations in size and shape. The aim of this study is to evaluate the biomechanical properties of different pilot hole profiles corresponding to various surgical approaches. Commercially available synthetic L4 vertebrae with a density of 0.16 g/cc were utilized as substitutes for human bone. Four different pilot hole profiles were created using a 3.0 mm cylindrical bone biopsy needle, 3.6 mm cylindrical drill, 3.2–5.0 mm conical drill, and 3.2–5.0 mm conical curette for simulating various minimally invasive and traditional spinal surgeries. Two frequently employed screw shapes, namely, cylindrical and conical, were selected. Following specimen preparation, screw pullout tests were performed using a material test machine, and statistical analysis was applied to compare the mean maximal pullout strength of each configuration. Conical and cylindrical screws in these four pilot hole configurations showed similar trends, with the mean maximal pullout strength ranking from high to low as follows: 3.0 mm cylindrical biopsy needle, 3.6 mm cylindrical drill bit, 3.2–5.0 mm conical curette, and 3.2–5.0 mm conical drill bit. Conical screws generally exhibited a greater mean maximal pullout strength than cylindrical screws in three of the four different pilot hole configurations. In the groups with conical pilot holes, created with a 3.2–5.0 mm drill bit and 3.2–5.0 mm curette, both conical screws exhibited a greater mean maximal pullout strength than did cylindrical screws. The strength of this study lies in its comprehensive comparison of the impact of various pilot hole profiles commonly used in clinical procedures on screw fixation stability, a topic rarely reported in the literature. Our results demonstrated that pilot holes created for minimally invasive surgery using image-guided techniques exhibit superior pullout strength compared to those utilized in traditional surgery. Therefore, we recommend prioritizing minimally invasive surgery when screw implantation is anticipated to be difficult or there is a specific need for stronger screw fixation. When opting for traditional surgery, image-guided methods may help establish smaller pilot holes and increase screw fixation strength.

Screw Pull-out Strength After Pedicle Screw Reposition: a Finite Element Analysis

Relationship of Vertebral Body Bone Mineral Density with Insertional Torque and Pull-out Strengths of Pedicle Screws and Its Clinical Significance

A Study of Screw Placement to Obtain the Optimal Pull-out Resistance of Lumbar Pedicle Screws—analysis of Hounsfield Units Measurements Based on Computed Tomography

Craniocaudal cyclic load improve risk assessment of lumbar pedicle screw loosening：finite element analysis based on computer tomography

Stability Of Medially And Laterally Malpositioned Screws: A Biomechanical Study On Cadavers

Biomechanical Analysis of Pedicle Screw Reinsertion Along the Same Trajectory in a Validated 3D-Printed Synthetic Bone Model

Finite Element Method-Based Study of Pedicle Screw–bone Connection in Pullout Test and Physiological Spinal Loads

Biomechanical effects of posterior lumbar interbody fusion with vertical placement of pedicle screws compared to traditional placement

Revision of pedicle screw applied to low Imnbar disease postoperatively

A Novel Screw Modeling Approach to Study the Effects of Screw Parameters on Pullout Strength.

Investigation of toggling effect on pullout performance of pedicle screws

Evaluation of the reduction, tightening and gripping performance of an innovative set screw technology for instrumented posterior lumbar fusion: A biomechanical study

Impact of screw tip design on screw anchorage: mechanical testing and numerical simulation

Pullout performance comparison of pedicle screws based on cement application and design parameters

Biomechanical Comparison of Fixation Stability among Various Pedicle Screw Geometries: Effects of Screw Outer/Inner Projection Shape and Thread Profile

Incomplete insertion of pedicle screws triggers a higher biomechanical risk of screw loosening: mechanical tests and corresponding numerical simulations

Influence of various pilot hole profiles on pedicle screw fixation strength in minimally invasive and traditional spinal surgery: a comparative biomechanical study

Stress Distribution in Vertebral Bone and Pedicle Screw and Screw-Bone Load Transfers among Various Fixation Methods for Lumbar Spine Surgical Alignment: A Finite Element Study

Pedicle screw augmentation in posterior constructs of the thoracolumbar spine: How many pedicle screws should be augmented?

Treatment of Thoracolumbar Fractures Through Different Short Segment Pedicle Screw Fixation Techniques: A Finite Element Analysis

Finite element analysis comparing a PEEK posterior fixation device versus pedicle screws for lumbar fusion