Abstract:Evaluating the physical mechanisms that link hydraulic fracturing (HF) operations to induced earthquakes and the anticipated form of the resulting events is significant in informing subsurface fluid injection operations. Current understanding supports the overriding role of the effective stress magnitude in triggering earthquakes, while the impact of change rate of effective stress has not been systematically addressed. In this work, a modified critical stiffness was brought up to investigate the likelihood, impact, and mitigation of induced seismicity during and after hydraulic fracturing by developing a poroelastic model based on rate-and-state frictional law and linear stability analysis. In the new criterion, the change rate of effective stress was considered a key variable to explore the evolution of this criterion and hence the likelihood of instability slip of fault. A coupled fluid flow–deformation model was used to represent the entire hydraulic fracturing process in COMSOL Multiphysics. The possibility of triggering an earthquake throughout the entire hydraulic fracturing process, from fracturing to cessation, was investigated considering different fault locations, orientations, and positions along the fault. The competition between the effects of the magnitude and change rate of effective stress was notable at each fracturing stage. The effective stress magnitude is a significant controlling factor during fracturing events, with the change rate dominating when fracturing is suddenly started or stopped. Instability dominates when the magnitude of the effective stress increases (constant injection at each fracturing stage) and the change rate of effective stress decreases (the injection process is suddenly stopped). Fracturing with a high injection rate, a fault adjacent to the hydraulic fracturing location and the position of the junction between the reservoir and fault are important to reduce the Coulomb failure stress (CFS) and enhance the critical stiffness as the significant disturbance of stresses at these positions in the coupled process. Therefore, notable attention should be given to the injection rate during fracturing, fault position, and position along faults as important considerations to help reduce the potential for induced seismicity. Our model was verified and confirmed using the case of the Longmaxi Formation in the Sichuan Basin, China, in which the reported microseismic data were correlated with high critical stiffness values. This work supplies new thoughts of the seismic risk associated with HF engineering.

Large‐scale fracture systems are permeable pathways for fault activation during hydraulic fracturing

Interaction of natural and hydraulic fractures: the impact on reservoir pressure buildup and risk of shear fault reactivation in the Upper Devonian Duvernay Formation, Fox Creek, Alberta

Spatiotemporal variations in earthquake triggering mechanisms during multistage hydraulic fracturing in Western Canada

Sealing faults and fluid-induced seismicity

Stress Chatter on a Fracture Network Reactivated by Hydraulic Fracturing

Implications for fault reactivation and seismicity induced by hydraulic fracturing

Normal Fault Reactivation Induced by Hydraulic Fracturing: Poroelastic Effects

An Overview of New Developments in Shale Gas: Induced Seismicity Aspect

Fault activation by hydraulic fracturing in western Canada

Surface Microseismic Monitoring of Hydraulic Fracturing of a Shale-Gas Reservoir Using Short-Period and Broadband Seismic Sensors

Stress Chatter Via Fluid Flow and Fault Slip in a Hydraulic Fracturing‐Induced Earthquake Sequence in the Montney Formation, British Columbia

Frictional Stabilities on Induced Earthquake Fault Planes at Fox Creek, Alberta: A Pore Fluid Pressure Dilemma

Earthquakes Triggered by Fluid Diffusion and Boosted by Fault Reactivation in Weiyuan, China Due to Hydraulic Fracturing

The Role of Fault-Zone Architectural Elements on Pore Pressure Propagation and Induced Seismicity

Hydraulic Fracturing, Fault System Architecture, and the Details of Anthropogenic Earthquakes in the Post-Pennsylvanian Delaware Basin of West Texas

Developments in understanding seismicity triggered by hydraulic fracturing

Post-injection normal closure of fractures as a mechanism for induced seismicity

Maturity of nearby faults influences seismic hazard from hydraulic fracturing

Modeling of Injection Induced Seismic Events

Fracture Activation and Induced Seismicity During Long-Term Heat Production in Fractured Geothermal Reservoirs

New insight into mechanisms of fracture network generation in shale gas reservoir