Abstract:Transcranial ultrasonic stimulation (TUS) is rapidly emerging as a promising non-invasive neuromodulation technique. TUS is already well-established in animal models, providing foundations to now optimize neuromodulatory efficacy for human applications. Across multiple studies, one promising protocol, pulsed at 1000 Hz, has consistently resulted in motor cortical inhibition in humans (Fomenko et al., 2020). At the same time, a parallel research line has highlighted the potentially confounding influence of peripheral auditory stimulation arising from TUS pulsing at audible frequencies. In this study, we disentangle direct neuromodulatory and indirect auditory contributions to motor inhibitory effects of TUS. To this end, we include tightly matched control conditions across four experiments, one preregistered, conducted independently at three institutions. We employed a combined transcranial ultrasonic and magnetic stimulation paradigm, where TMS-elicited motor-evoked potentials (MEPs) served as an index of corticospinal excitability. First, we replicated motor inhibitory effects of TUS but showed through both tight controls and manipulation of stimulation intensity, duration, and auditory masking conditions that this inhibition was driven by peripheral auditory stimulation, not direct neuromodulation. Furthermore, we consider neuromodulation beyond driving overall excitation/inhibition and show preliminary evidence of how TUS might interact with ongoing neural dynamics instead. Primarily, this study highlights the substantial shortcomings in accounting for the auditory confound in prior TUS-TMS work where only a flip-over sham and no active control was used. The field must critically reevaluate previous findings given the demonstrated impact of peripheral confounds. Furthermore, rigorous experimental design via (in)active control conditions is required to make substantiated claims in future TUS studies. Only when direct effects are disentangled from those driven by peripheral confounds can TUS fully realize its potential for research and clinical applications.

Transcranial ultrasound neuromodulation of the thalamic visual pathway in a large animal model and the dose-response relationship with MR-ARFI

Transcranial focused ultrasound modulates visual thalamus in a nonhuman primate model

Ultrasound system for precise neuromodulation of human deep brain circuits

Microscopic deconstruction of cortical circuit stimulation by transcranial ultrasound

Dynamical and individualised approach of transcranial ultrasound neuromodulation effects in non-human primates

Transcranial Low-Intensity Focused Ultrasound Stimulation of the Visual Thalamus Produces Long-Term Depression of Thalamocortical Synapses in the Adult Visual Cortex

Transcranial focused ultrasound-mediated neurochemical and functional connectivity changes in deep cortical regions in humans

Noninvasive intervention by transcranial ultrasound stimulation: Modulation of neural circuits and its clinical perspectives

Transcranial Focused Ultrasound Remotely Modulates Extrastriate Visual Cortex with Subregion Specificity

Current state of clinical ultrasound neuromodulation

Auditory independent low-intensity ultrasound stimulation of mouse brain is associated with neuronal ERK phosphorylation and an increase of Tbr2 marked neuroprogenitors

Accelerated Transcranial Ultrasound Neuromodulation in Parkinson's Disease: A Pilot Study

Noninvasive modulation of essential tremor with focused ultrasonic waves

Auditory confounds can drive online effects of transcranial ultrasonic stimulation in humans

Biophysical effects and neuromodulatory dose of transcranial ultrasonic stimulation

Model-based navigation of transcranial focused ultrasound neuromodulation in humans: Application to targeting the amygdala and thalamus

A novel transcranial MR Guided focused ultrasound method based on the ultrashort echo time skull acoustic model and phase retrieval techniques

Optimization of MR-ARFI for Human Transcranial Focused Ultrasound

Transcranial Functional Ultrasound Imaging Detects Focused Ultrasound Neuromodulation Induced Hemodynamic Changes in Mouse and Nonhuman Primate Brains

Focal Volume, Acoustic Radiation Force, and Strain in Two-Transducer Regimes

Neuromodulation with Ultrasound: Hypotheses on the Directionality of Effects and a Community Resource