Abstract:Methods for clustering people into construals--social affinity groups of individuals who share similarities in how they organize their outlooks on a collection of issues--have recently gained traction. Relational Class Analysis (RCA) is currently the most commonly used method for construal clustering. RCA has been applied to identify affinity groups in social spheres as varied as politics, musical preferences, and attitudes towards science. In this study, we highlight limitations in RCA's ability to accurately identify the number and underlying structure of construals. These limitations stem from RCA's mathematical underpinnings and its insensitivity to the bipolar structure of the survey items, which require respondents to place themselves in a support or rejection space and then express the intensity of their support or rejection. We develop an alternative method, which we call Bipolar Class Analysis (BCA), that aims to address this foundational limitation. BCA conceptualizes people's attitudinal positions as moving along support/rejection semispaces and assesses similarity in opinion organization by taking into account position switches across these semispaces. We conduct extensive simulation analyses, with data organized around different construals, to demonstrate that BCA clusters individuals more accurately than RCA and other available alternatives. We also replicate previous analyses to show that BCA leads to substantively different empirical results than those produced by RCA in its original and later versions, and by Correlational Clustering Analysis (CCA), a method that has been proposed as an alternative to RCA.

Operationalizing relational construal level to test relational turbulence theory: Linking relational turbulence in romantic relationships to interpersonal processes

Construal Level Theory: A Review of the Literature

The Interplay of Regulatory Fit and Construal Level in Influencing Behavioral Intention

Boundary spanner closeness to partner firm as relational governance in turbulent versus stable environments

The Role of Relational Orientation As Measured by Face and Renqing in Innovative Behavior in China: an Indigenous Analysis

Distance-construal relationship: Mediating role of perceived control and moderating role of locus of control

Construal Levels and Psychological Distance: Effects on Representation, Prediction, Evaluation, and Behavior

Cultural Effects on Relationality in Negotiations: an Experimental Study

Religious Conversations and Relational Uncertainty in Romantic Relationships as Mediators of Family Communication Patterns and Young Adults’ Mental Well-being

Forms of social relationships in distinct cultural settings

Toward a Relational Theory of Employee Engagement: Understanding Authenticity, Transparency, and Employee Behaviors

Development and validation of the relational behavior interactions scale for couples

Reassessing Relationality for Bipolar Data

Emotional worlds colliding: A qualitative exploration of the emotional experiences of transgender and cisgender women in romantic relationships during transition

Buying Insurance for Harmony: A Relational Risk Perspective on Conflict Avoidance

Relational processes of cultural humility in counseling: A structural equation modeling study

Chinese young adults' emotion regulation and conflict resolution response profiles, and their associations with perceived partner responsiveness and romantic relationship satisfaction

Implicit Theories of Relationships: Who Cares if Romantic Partners Are Less than Ideal?

The relationships between affect dimensions and level of construal

The Implicit Sociometer Effect and the Moderating Role of Relational Self-Construal.

Are relational contracting principles applicable to public construction projects?