Assessing the aquatic toxicity and environmental safety of tracer compounds Rhodamine B and Rhodamine WT
L.M. Skjolding,L.vG. Jørgensen,K.S. Dyhr,C.J. Köppl,U.S. McKnight,P. Bauer-Gottwein,P. Mayer,P.L. Bjerg,A. Baun
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.watres.2021.117109
IF: 12.8
2021-06-01
Water Research
Abstract:<p>Tracer tests represent a well-established method for delineating key environmental processes in various media and engineered systems. Tracers like Rhodamine B and WT are frequently applied due to their strong fluorescence even at low concentrations.. However, due to a lack of ecotoxicological data, limit values for these tracers cannot be determined. This study fills this critical data gap by providing ecotoxicity data for Rhodamine B and WT using a battery of short-term standardized tests, including growth rate inhibition tests with algae (<em>Raphidocelis subcapitata</em>) and lethality tests using crustaceans (<em>Daphnia magna</em>) and zebrafish (<em>Danio rerio</em>) embryos, and estimating EQS for surface water. For Rhodamine B, the effective and lethal concentration (EC<sub>50</sub> and LC<sub>50</sub>) –causing 50% toxicity were in the range of 14-24 mg/L. For Rhodamine WT, no statistically significant effects were observed (p<0.05) at the tsted concentrations (up to 91, 100 and 200 mg/L for algae, crustaceans and fish embryos, respectively). Thus for all tested organisms, Rhodamine B was more toxic than Rhodamine WT (more than 14 times more toxic for <em>R. subcapitata</em>, 5.6 times for <em>D. magna</em>, 15 times for <em>D. rerio</em> embryos, based on EC<sub>10</sub> and LC<sub>10</sub> values). These results signify that read-across assessments using ecotoxicity data obtained with Rhodamine B is not advisable for estimating the ecotoxicity of Rhodamine WT. The annual-average quality standard (AA-QS) and maximum allowable concentration quality standard (MAC-QS) for Rhodamine B were found to be 14 and 140 µg/L, respectively. For Rhodamine WT, the corresponding values were estimated to >91 µg/L (AA-QS) and >910 µg/L (MAC-QS). Hence, concentrations below 140 µg/L or 910 µg/L for Rhodamine B and WT, respectively, are not expected to pose a risk to aquatic freshwater life in the case of intermittent discharges, e.g. tracer experiments released in streams.</p>
environmental sciences,engineering, environmental,water resources