Welding Journal-February 2011
J. SHEN,Y. S. ZHANG,X. M. LAI,P. C. WANG
2011-01-01
Abstract:The automotive industry is constantly seeking product and production optimization. Resistance spot welding is a key technology in automotive assembly production. The process is fast and can easily weld many different material combinations that are difficult or even impossible to join by other welding techniques. The development of new, advanced highstrength steels (AHSS) for use in the automotive industry represents new challenges to the resistance welding of these steels. These new steel types are often used in supporting parts of the car and in parts that are designed to absorb the impact of a crash. The parts are typically joined to considerably thinner and softer low-carbon sheet materials that act as the outer panels of the car. The weldability of different AHSS in two-layer lap joints has been investigated by several authors including the present ones (Refs. 1–5). Problems due to the formation of hard martensite phases during the rapid cooling after welding increase the risk of the joints having brittle fracture. Narrow weld lobes initiated work (Ref. 6), where an insulating adhesive layer is added between the sheets to form a weld bond. The adhesive layer increases the heat and, thereby, the nugget size due to higher contact resistance. Wider weld lobes were shown, but the addition of the adhesive layer complicates the assembly process. Joining three sheets by resistance spot welding is an increasing trend in automotive assembly. Compared to two-sheet spot welding, joining three sheets is significantly more complicated because of the extra interface introduced. The use of different material combinations and different sheet thicknesses in the three layers complicates the process even further. Spot welding of three low-carbon steel sheets was investigated (Ref. 7), where it was recommended that three-sheet spot welding should be avoided whenever it could be replaced by two spot welds of two sheets. Among the difficulties were coating, varying surface quality, and enhanced alignment problems between three sheets compared to two. Successful welds were made, but it was shown that the three-sheet welds are more sensitive to changing parameters. Lack of confidence in weld quality is also mentioned for spot welding three sheets (Ref. 8), which in industry results in many more welds than actually needed for the required structural performance. In their study, the focus was on the heat development for uncoated and coated lowcarbon steels. For these steels, they obtain acceptable weld qualities for three-sheet welding. When resistance spot welding three sheets, the joint has two sheet-to-sheet interfaces with positions relative to each other and the electrodes depending on the individual sheet thicknesses. If one of the outer sheets is considerably thinner than the other two sheets, the interface between this and the center sheet is located closer to the neighboring electrode than the other interface. In this case, the large heat conduction to the electrode creates an asymmetrical heat distribution causing problems achieving a successful weld. If the heat input is too small, the nugget will not develop in the thinner sheet, and the weld will be unsuccessful. On the other hand, if the heat input is too large, splash is often observed between the two thicker sheets, leading to uncontrollable material removal, loss of strength, and excessive electrode wear. In many cases, this implies unsatisfactory weld strength. Of importance to car manufacturing, spot welding of a thin, low-carbon steel sheet to two thicker, high-strength steels is an example with the above complications. Innovative solutions to the above type of three-sheet spot welding have been developed (Refs. 9, 10). One solution (Ref. 9) is intelligent control of the electrode force and current levels to ensure nugget formation in both interfaces. Using a high current and low force setting in the beginning of the weld, a nugget is formed in the interface between the thin, low-carbon Three-Sheet Spot Welding of Advanced High-Strength Steels