Abstract:Different mathematical models can be developed to represent the dynamic behavior of structural systems and assess properties, such as risk of failure and reliability. Selecting an adequate model requires choosing a model of sufficient complexity to accurately capture the output responses under various operational conditions. However, as model complexity increases, the functional relationship between input parameters varies and the number of parameters required to represent the physical system increases, reducing computational efficiency and increasing modeling difficulty. The process of model selection is further exacerbated by uncertainty introduced from input parameters, noise in experimental measurements, numerical solutions, and model form. The purpose of this research is to evaluate the acceptable level of uncertainty that can be present within numerical models, while reliably capturing the fundamental physics of a subject system. However, before uncertainty quantification can be performed, a sensitivity analysis study is required to prevent numerical ill-conditioning from parameters that contribute insignificant variability to the output response features of interest. The main focus of this paper, therefore, is to employ sensitivity analysis tools on models to remove low sensitivity parameters from the calibration space. The subject system in this study is a modular spring-damper system integrated into a space truss structure. Six different cases of increasing complexity are derived from a mathematical model designed from a two-degree of freedom (2DOF) mass spring-damper that neglects single truss properties, such as geometry and truss member material properties. Model sensitivity analysis is performed using the Analysis of Variation (ANOVA) and the Coefficient of Determination R2. The global sensitivity results for the parameters in each 2DOF case are determined from the R2 calculation and compared in performance to evaluate levels of parameter contribution. Parameters with a weighted R2 value less than .02 account for less than 2% of the variation in the output responses and are removed from the calibration space. This paper concludes with an outlook on implementing Bayesian inference methodologies, delayed-acceptance single-component adaptive Metropolis (DA-SCAM) algorithm and Gaussian Process Models for Simulation Analysis (GPM/SA), to select the most representative mathematical model and set of input parameters that best characterize the system’s dynamic behavior.

Quantifying modeling uncertainty in simplified beam models for building response prediction

A Ductility-Centred Analytical Model for Axially Restrained Double-Span Steel Beam Systems Subjected to Sudden Columns Loss

Quantification of modeling uncertainty in the Rayleigh damping model

Probabilistic Code-Based Shear Capacity Model for I-shaped Steel Reinforced Concrete (SRC) Beams

Structural modal identification and MCMC-based model updating by a Bayesian approach

Modeling and Response Prediction in Performance-Based Seismic Evaluation: Case Studies of Instrumented Steel Moment-Frame Buildings

Bayesian model updating of a 20-story office building utilizing operational modal analysis results

Applying Uncertainty Quantification to Structural Systems: Parameter Reduction for Evaluating Model Complexity

A hybrid model-data method for seismic response reconstruction of instrumented buildings

An inelastic beam-like model for nonlinear dynamic analyses of multi-storey buildings

Assessing uncertainty in fast Bayesian modal identification based on seismic structural responses

Uncertainty Quantification in Friction Model for Earthquakes using Bayesian inference

Quantification of the resistance modeling uncertainty of 19 alternative 2D nonlinear finite element approaches benchmarked against 101 experiments on reinforced concrete beams

Quantifying Uncertainty in Material Damage from Vibrational Data

Quantifying uncertainty in free vibration characteristics of nanobeam with one variable first-order shear deformation theory: an analytical investigation

Impact of Probabilistic Modeling Alternatives on the Seismic Fragility Analysis of Reinforced Concrete Dual Wall–Frame Buildings towards Resilient Designs

Vibration-based Bayesian model updating of civil engineering structures applying Gaussian process metamodel

An efficient method based on shear models for structural seismic response prediction considering hysteretic characteristics

Data-Driven Uncertainty Quantification and Propagation in Structural Dynamics through a Hierarchical Bayesian Framework

A Nonlinear Computational Model for Regional Seismic Simulation of Tall Buildings

Probabilistic seismic demand assessment accounting for finite element model class uncertainty: Application to a code‐designed URM infilled reinforced concrete frame building